Li really like the idea of cleaning up the shop values, especially removing really generic ones.
But specific ones have their place For example, electronics is a good shop value, but what about a ham radio store? Generic hobby shops exist, what about model train shops? We need to create a skeleton that has sub values, or we need to allow (usually on a region by region basis) more detailed tags than is what expected. For example, in Japan, a "bath fixtures" shop is a common store. They sell toilets, showers, tubs, etc. there are plenty of big home stores that that slo sell those, but the local "bath fixture shop" is a common sight. Same with "bamboo home goods" and "tea goods" for loose tea, powered macha, special teapots, and the accessories for the pots. You can not buy a drink there, just goods to make tea. W A skeleton of premade sub keys that can accept specific values shop=hobby, hobby=trains or an acceptance of more specific values ( similar to cuisine - octopus ball stands are fast food here) need to dealt with in a proper way. Javbw > On Oct 7, 2015, at 10:58 PM, Daniel Koć <daniel@koć.pl> wrote: > > I was trying to review the shop values we show in osm-carto (top 100 > according to TagInfo - you can list it by running this Ruby script: > https://github.com/gravitystorm/openstreetmap-carto/blob/master/scripts/shop_values.rb > ) and here are my quick findings: > > No wiki page or definition (some of them can be also candidates for > deprecating and replacing with something else): > > builder > building_materials > craft > discount > energy > flooring > gallery > games > health_food > hobby > market > phone > real_estate > rental > salon > shoe_repair > tiles > > Candidates for deprecating: > > antique - no wiki, mentioned on antiques page so maybe deprecate and propose > antiques? > appliance - wiki redirects to electronics, so maybe deprecate and propose > electronics instead? > car_service - maybe car_repair? > communication - wiki redirects to mobile_phone, so maybe deprecate and > propose mobile_phone? > general - deprecate and propose to look for other shop values (like "yes")? > health - medical_supply? > household - houseware? > interior_decoration - houseware? > office_supplies - stationery? > printing - copyshop? > radiotechnics - electronics? > sewing - maybe tailor? > shopping_centre - mall? > solarium - leisure=tanning_salon? > souvenir - gift? > tanning - leisure=tanning_salon? > > Also organic is deprecated, but I was told that it was made by one person, so > we should also decide if we support this change or we want to revert it. > > What are your propositions? > > -- > "The train is always on time / The trick is to be ready to put your bags > down" [A. Cohen] > > _______________________________________________ > Tagging mailing list > Tagging@openstreetmap.org > https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging _______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list Tagging@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
