Hi Javbw.
Thanks for the feedback.
We don’t intent to map circus. I just had problems coming up with a good
example for temporary building, so kinda resulted in some ambiguity around it.
> If you want to map such local and temporary structures, please set a personal
> reminder in your calendar app on your phone to go remove it. Otherwise it may
> stay there for years.
I think in this case the user specifies the end-date when they fill in the
preset. If he doesn’t specify the end-date we will give him the alert like: By
not specifying the end date you mean this temporary structure is there for
indeterminate amount of time and is not intended to be moved. Confirm / Cancel.
I think we also need a server-side that tracks such temporary buildings and
remove them once the due date is reached? I doubt the user will go and manually
remove the building one-month later even if we remind him.
> There are some “temporary” structures that are permanent: a Bus is used as an
> office for a nearby driving school because no permanent structures are
> allowed to be built in the area. That bus has been parked in the same spot
> for over 10 years, (moved only during typhoons), so I consider it permanent
> and mappable - a much larger erection (like a circus tent) only there for a
> month is much more “temporary” than that bus.
So that is what we have classified as semi-permanent. (I have pointed in my
previous comment)
>> Thanks for explaining. So then in order to have no confusion, we give user
>> the binary selection:
>> {permanent, temporary}. If he selects temporary -> he can then optionally
>> with a date picker specify the end date.
>> That would then map to your guidelines.
So I guess just like we just said above - user doesn’t specify the end-date and
he confirms that this is an indeterminate temporary feature (semi-permanent).
Does this goes well?
Thanks!
Best,
Taras.
> On 27 Jul 2017, at 8:48 PM, John Willis <[email protected]> wrote:
>
>
>
>> On Jul 27, 2017, at 3:52 PM, Vozniuk Taras <[email protected]>
>> wrote:
>>
>> So non-permanent is a building structure constructed for a defined short
>> period of time. Like Circus tent for example. It stays there for a defined 1
>> month.
>
> Unless it is for some international event (like the olympics, World Cup, etc)
> I would not map buildings that would be there for a month, especially
> something as local as a circus.
>
> If you want to map such local and temporary structures, please set a personal
> reminder in your calendar app on your phone to go remove it. Otherwise it may
> stay there for years.
>
> There are some “temporary” structures that are permanent: a Bus is used as an
> office for a nearby driving school because no permanent structures are
> allowed to be built in the area. That bus has been parked in the same spot
> for over 10 years, (moved only during typhoons), so I consider it permanent
> and mappable - a much larger erection (like a circus tent) only there for a
> month is much more “temporary” than that bus.
>
> Javbw.
> _______________________________________________
> Tagging mailing list
> [email protected]
> https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
_______________________________________________
Tagging mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
