On 27/07/18 11:38, Tod Fitch wrote:
On Jul 26, 2018, at 5:45 PM, Kevin Kenny <[email protected]> wrote:
The only outcome of that thread - and several threads on the same
subject that preceded it - was that there was no consensus.
I’ve been following the talk and tagging lists for a couple of years now and
don’t think I’ve seen consensus on anything.
My take is to toss an idea/problem into the list and see if there is anything
that comes back in the first few days that alters your opinion on how to tag.
Sometimes there are good suggestions that can improve your thinking on how
something should be tagged so it is worth submitting. Just be prepared to read
and delete a myriad of email that is basically bike shedding by people who seem
to have never been out of their cultural home area.
Then just go for it and tag things. Better if you document your tagging, at
least as a proposal.
On Jul 26, 2018, at 6:15 PM, Warin <[email protected]> wrote:
Just use the tag. 245 in the data base now.
As for fees they can be tagged with fee= tag
As for the permit conditions .. well you could just tag permit=*
I'd just do it. Overpass turbo shows a wide distribution around the world.
It makes much more sense that some tags already on the wiki.
I may well add it to the wiki, documents tags in the data base. While small in
number it does show what they are about and may help others to use them
appropriately rather than inappropriately or just ignore them through ignorance.
There are some that don't show up in a simple search .. for the Overland Track
relation 1673569 in Tasmania, Australia I have
access:conditional=permit@ 1 Oct - 31 May
fee:conditional=yes@ 1 Oct - 31 May
Not certain how to include those with access=permit.
I haven’t bother to check, but if there is a world wide distribution of people
who have decided that access=permit makes sense then I agree that it a good
thing to document it on the wiki.
OverpassTurbo search on "access=permit" brings them up.
Apart for the places already mentioned there are
1 in Wales
a number in England
Belgium, Germany, Austria, Mozambique, Japan.
Note 50 of these are on nodes, possibly marking an entry point.
_______________________________________________
Tagging mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
