Le 26. 10. 18 à 09:28, SelfishSeahorse a écrit : > What about tagging the presence or absence of traffic signals with a > subkey, e.g. crossing:traffic_signals=yes/no?
it is indeed always possible to take out all the values to make them keys. but if iD only enters the marking in crossing_ref like the other editors, the crossing key will again indicate whether or not there is a light. so is it useful to change the name of the key there too? experience shows that if you want to change everything, in the end nothing changes because many contributors have started from immobility when the solution is too large. that is why I think it is useful to focus on how to correctly inform the type of ground marking > I've already proposed to replace crossing=island with > crossing:island=yes [1] for the same reason, that is, because when > using crossing=island, it's not possible to specify if the pedestrian > crossing is marked or not. > [1]: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Proposed_features/Key:crossing:island It's a good idea (and I like that the propal focus on one tag/issue in order to hope that this will facilitate its adoption _______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list [email protected] https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
