I'd still suggest
addr:city=Brisbane
addr:suburb=The Gap
This follows the full addressing, I don't know if there is any other
suburb "The Gap" but imagine two suburbs A_suburb in two different cites
A_city and B_city in the same state in the same country.
The if you put:
addr:city=A_suburb
addr:state=state
addr:country=country
Then which one are you talking about.
Where as if you put:
addr:suburb=A_suburb
addr:city=A_city or B_city
addr:state=state
addr:country=country
Then it's immediately apparent which is which.
Just my thoughts.
Cheers
Ross
On 19/01/14 13:00, Stéphane Guillou wrote:
Thanks everyone for your input.
I wonder what was the rationale behind using abbreviations for countries
and states as I understood that the database must be as human-readable
as possible.
Still, I will be following the recommendations on the Key:addr page for
addr:country=AU.
However, I am still unsure about suburb vs city. Key:addr tells us to
watch out for the Australian definition of suburbs, and Wikipedia says
the following:
"In Australia and New Zealand, suburbs have become formalised as
geographic subdivisions of a city and are used by postal services in
*addressing*."
As we are here tagging the address, I was wondering: are we tagging so
the addresses appear as they should when we use them (e.g. when we write
them on an envelope) - the original point of tagging an address I guess
- (in which case I would just go with addr:city=The Gap), or should we
understand the tags as literally as possible (in that case, I would go
addr:city=Brisbane and addr:suburb=The Gap).
What would be the best way to decide on a convention so we can add
guidelines for OSM-AU?
Cheers
Stéphane (chtfn)
On 19/01/14 11:04, Ross Scanlon wrote:
I'd suggest you check this page
http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key:addr
You'll see that the addr:country is supposed to be:
"The ISO 3166-1 alpha-2 two letter country code in upper case."
We are talking addresses not is_in.
Also addr:state can be either but it tends to be the abbreviation.
Cheers
Ross
_______________________________________________
Talk-au mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-au
