Le mer. 22 janv. 2020 à 20:57, Jorge Sanz Sanfructuoso <sanc...@gmail.com> a écrit :
> No he dicho que te inventaras "Enclave de Treviño", sino que el que este > ese bien o mal puesto no te da derecho para inventarte otros nombres. El > que te has inventado es «Enclaves burgueses de Miranda de Ebro» > > Como no hay admin_level7 en España cojo me lo invento y que se aguantes > los Españoles. Ole tú. Gran argumento el tuyo. ¿Y si no existe, cómo lo > quieres poner, que en gran parte de España parece que es el > caso?¿imponiéndolo? Esto es lo que se te lleva explicando desde el minuto 1 > pero en vez de dialogar impones que se pone lo que tu dices, como tu dices. > Clamos ! I'm not alone to have created such mixed and unqualified things at admin_level 7, because the OSM documentation wiki was not clear at all. They were spread by multiple users (not just me) that created them over time without consiudering this was an issue and without asking here. It's not the fact they they do not exist, but they are ambiguously tagged and largely incomplete (when in fact they come from administrative sources that are complete in their relevant area of coverage). In OSM this was largely an unfinished subset of data that has never been usable for any purpose. I do not impose the tagging, I just created one that hoped to be coherent by itself and tried to sort the mess. But it remains unfinished. This is still a "work in progress"... And I used the correct sources or what appeared to be the existing consensus (anyway Spanish users do not seem to have properly sortted things as well in Wikipedia, Commons and Wikidata). Someboday must start "doing the hard job" and find these incoherences. That was me, and of course I'm exposed to critics, but not opposed to changes and better suggestions, and I'm very open to them. If I make errors I can and will fix them. It's a fact that even if these comarcas are not officialized by the autonomous communities, they are officialized by a Spanish administration (provinces, ministries, state agencies) for their domain of use, so they exist (even in their own open data sets) and they are expected to be present in OSM (otherwise other Spanish users wouldn't have created some of them, but left the situation unfinished and incoherent, so they were still not usable). Those administrations unfortunately designate them as "comarca", but if you read their sources correctly, the term "comarca" is not used alone and is qualified.
_______________________________________________ Talk-es mailing list Talk-es@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-es
