On 18/03/2009 11:21, Ed Loach wrote: >>> one in Bury St Edmunds is tagged landuse=industrial (with a >> visitor >>> centre attraction). >> That was me. It really is a factory, so I felt industrial was >> appropriate. > > No, I agree. I've seen the place and it is very industrial. But > landuse to me seems more appropriate for areas, so not much help > with me just tagging a node (Farmers Brewery is essentially a > microbrewery with capacity for I believe 8 barrels which was > dictated by door width and ceiling height limiting what vessels they > could get into the space available which is part of some out > buildings for the adjacent hotel). > > For tagging the node I considered > * building=brewery (Map Features says area only though original > proposal also mentions node) > * shop=brewery (they do also have a shop for bottled beers adjacent > to the brewery) > * amenity=brewery (as I picked "pub" in JOSM and manually changed > pub to brewery, which is how it is currently tagged) > * man_made=brewery (though it wasn't originally made to be a > brewery) > and so on. > > There is one standalone brewery (Harwich) in the Essex district I > live in and tend to map, and I've not tagged it yet. There are also > a couple of pubs which contain microbreweries, but they're only > tagged as pubs so far with no mention that they have associated > breweries (e.g. Cross Inn, Great Bromley for Sticklegs Brewery and > the Railway Tavern, Brightlingsea contains "The Railway Tavern > Brewing Co."). Perhaps it isn't important though.
My point was, though, that if brewery deserves to be identified, then so do all other business/industrail premises, as we have started doing shops. Therefore using "some_existing_tag"=brewery isn't so good. So maybe we need factory=brewery|printers|clothing etc like shop(*) Micro-breweries are perhaps a different matter, and by coincidence there is also one of these in Bury St Edmunds, here: href="http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=52.24951&lon=0.71468&zoom=17&layers=B000FTFTT&mlat=52.24962&mlon=0.71470 Is this just perhaps some additional property of something already marked amenity=pub? David (*) PS I know some people aren't going to like this, but in retail parks with big shed type shops, I've taken to marking landuse=retail and then putting nodes marked landuse=retail; name=whatever within them sop identify individual shops. I'd use shop=... except that the names aren't rendered then (and yes, that's tagging for the renderer). I guess I could also do both. Ditto individual large factories in industrial estates (landuse=industrial). Examples of both side-by-die also in Bury: http://www.openstreetmap.org/?lat=52.23952&lon=0.74751&zoom=16&layers=B000FTTT _______________________________________________ Talk-GB mailing list [email protected] http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-gb
