On 29 May 2012, at 12:51, Worst Fixer wrote:
> Hello.
>
> I ask you to review my planned edit.
>
> There are lot of ways to tag intermittent water feature found in database.
> Most popular is intermittent=yes. All others come from different old imports.
> Date ist 2009-2010 year. I countiered ~350 000 features tagged in different
> such ways. Most is done by 10 users.
>
> I ask users iandees and SK53 join discussion, as most of such tags were
> imported by them. Others welcome too.
>
> I propose unification of tagging in all this imports.
>
> Following tags converted to intermittent=yes:
>
> frequency=intermittent
> occurrence=intermittent
> stream=intermittent
> water=intermittent
> type=intermittent
>
> Following tags converted to intermittent=no:
>
> frequency=perennial
> stream=perennial
>
> stream=ephemeral converted to intermittent=ephemeral.
>
> Just removed stream=fixme.
>
> Converted "fdate" field from NHD imports in iso8601 date, moved to check_date
> tag.
>
> Removed all id-like tags.
>
> If no valid objections will be raised, I upload this change on 2012-06-12.
>
> Here is overview:
> Short, to get the idea:
> http://worstfixer.000a.biz/04-intermittent/overview-short.html
> Long, for exact analysis:
> http://worstfixer.000a.biz/04-intermittent/overview-full.html.gz
>
> I currently looking for place to upload exact .osm.gz for a preview.
> Suggestions welcome.
Hi WorstFixer, I think this one might need a little more thought – what happens
to something previously tagged water=intermittent... it becomes
intermittent=yes... intermittent what? I doubt there's a nice way of
predicting what water= should become to make it correctly tagged.
Bob
_______________________________________________
talk mailing list
talk@openstreetmap.org
http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk
