Worst Fixer wrote:
I ask you to review my planned edit.

There are lot of ways to tag intermittent water feature found in database.
Most popular is intermittent=yes. All others come from different old
imports. Date ist 2009-2010 year. I countiered ~350 000 features tagged in
different such ways. Most is done by 10 users.

Following tags converted to intermittent=yes:

frequency=intermittent
occurrence=intermittent
stream=intermittent
water=intermittent
type=intermittent

Following tags converted to intermittent=no:

frequency=perennial
stream=perennial

While that doesn't sound unreasonable...

Short, to get the idea:
http://worstfixer.000a.biz/04-intermittent/overview-short.html

..this page actually lists many more tags that you propose to change. You're going to remove 9413 ele tags; why? No doubt at some point someone decided that "lake:shore_length:miles=2" was a useful thing to record, and you want to remove it. Why?

I have a suggestion: break your proposed edits into smaller chunks. For example, in this case, propose an edit that *only* makes the 'intermittent' change that I've quoted above. Then propose separate edits that make each of the other changes.


Regards,  Phil.





_______________________________________________
talk mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk

Reply via email to