On Tue, Nov 06, 2012 at 01:38:32PM +0100, Marc Espie wrote:
> Basically, we have a pattern, mostly observed with kde (and a bit with
> gnome) which is really harmful for us.
> 
> Those vendors say "we're not in the distribution business, distribution
> problems will be handled by OS vendors.  We can break compatibility to
> advance, and not think about it, this is not a problem."
> 
> This is a mindset we need to fight, and this has to be a grass-roots
> movement.
> 
> The main effect of THAT attitude is to *HURT* the  opensource community,
> big time. It's as harmful as the patent portfolio of big business.
> 
> Basically, it precludes smaller players from playing on a level field.
> As soon as you're different enough (and that's mostly NOT linux these
> days), you can't keep up. Those distribution problems are LARGE.
> 
> They occupy a few people in our team FULLTIME with respect to gnome, they're
> the reason we still DON'T have a full kde4 in our tree (hopefully to be
> addressed shortly), and they're the reason why sometimes we do drop old
> stuff (like killing gtk+1, and people really wanting to kill some gtk2/qt3
> stuff).
> 
> It takes a lot of manpower to address complex distribution issues. If you
> don't have tens of people, it becomes more and more of a losing battle,
> actually...
> 
> It's also quickly turning Posix and Unix into a travesty: either you have
> the linux goodies, or you don't. And if you don't, you can forget anything
> modern...
> 
> in some cases, you even have some people, who are PAID by some vendors,
> agressively pushing GRATUITOUS, non compatible changes. I won't say names,
> but you guys can fill the blanks in.
> 
> I'm pretty sure there's a lot of good intention behind the "progress" in
> recent desktops. But this is turning the field of OS distributions into
> a wasteland. Either you're a modern linux with pulseaudio and pam and
> systemd, or you're dying.  So much for the pionneer spirit of opensource,
> where you were free to innovate and do cool things, and more or less have
> interesting software able to run on your machine...

One could answer you that the BSD community is not involved enough with 
upstream. 99% of the development is done on Linux by developers using Linux -- 
if you want that to change, some !linux people should get involved in outside 
projects... I'm not saying I agree nor disagree with that statement, I'm just 
being the devil's advocate.

-- 
Antoine

Reply via email to