Mark, thanks for mentioning that related plugin. As far as I could tell on
my first browse-through when it was first announced, uni-link changes how
links display, but they still need to use [[hard markup|?]]. ("It allows
users to assign an aliases field to tiddlers, that can be referenced with a
slightly modified link syntax.")
My use case, though, involves chunks of text pasted into the wiki from
other sources, so I'm not wanting to go in and set up [[links-like-this|?]]
all over the place. The freelinking is essential, and my hack is designed
to cast a wider net for certain freelink-worthy terms.
Are you suggesting that uni-link would integrate with freelinks and help in
this use-case? Crucial to my situation: I still want the actual variant
strings within tiddlers to continue displaying *whatever it was* that the
original author typed...
So far, it strikes me that uni-link is designed for roughly the contrary
challenge to mine: a systematic single-author wiki where author wants to
use a concise markup to streamlines the cumbersome old [[workarounds for
plurals and such|workaround]], while also enabling retroactive global
changes to how certain [[hardlinked variants|c]] display. (So, if I change
my dog's nickname, all I do is update the caption field for the dog's
tiddler... Standard links to the dog's official name [[Rex]] still look and
function the same, but any uni-links via the caption [[Rex|c]] immediately
all show the new nickname. Cool! But not what I need to do...)
Happy to hear if you think I'm misunderstanding...
-Springer
On Monday, April 12, 2021 at 2:41:24 PM UTC-4 Mark S. wrote:
> Maybe uni-links <https://wikilabs.github.io/editions/uni-link> would be
> more useful, rather than having to apply multiple hacks?
>
> On Sunday, April 11, 2021 at 4:34:13 PM UTC-7 springer wrote:
>
>> Dear all,
>>
>> Freelinks are especially great when text gets dumped into a wiki from
>> multiple sources (such as students in a class, or excepts from texts), and
>> where the main author/curator of the wiki can't or shouldn't modify the
>> text generated by other authors.
>>
>> Currently, out of caution around potential performance-drag, I have
>> freelinks picking up titles for only a select set of tiddlers: those tagged
>> with *keyword *... and now also for *keyword-alias*. (In 5.1.24
>> prerelease: Filter defining tiddlers to which freelinks are made:
>> "[tag[keyword]] [tag[keyword-alias]]")
>>
>> I continue to hope that freelinks will one day work seamlessly with an
>> "aliases" or "title-variants" field... It's hard to imagine any person who
>> finds freelinks useful but who wouldn't benefit from getting title-variants
>> recognized without fuss.
>>
>> But for now, I'll share a very limited workaround, so that a freelink
>> (virtual link) to *empiricism* (or at least, a functional equivalent)
>> will display whenever tiddler text mentions empiric*ists* (for example).
>>
>> I actually generate a tiddler called empiricists and then populate it
>> with {{empiricism}}. I then set the caption field to empiricism, and add
>> the tag *keyword-alias*.
>>
>> Then, two tweaks to the system make it look almost seamless -- assuming
>> you don't really need to *see* titles rather than this more semantically
>> pointed (but not-necessarily-unique) caption field.
>>
>> (1a) Modify *$:/core/ui/ViewTemplate/title*
>>
>> *<$view field="title"/>* can be replaced with
>> *<$transclude field="caption">{{!!title}}</$transclude>*
>>
>> (1b) Do the same for *$:/core/macros/timeline* (if the Recents sidebar
>> tab is front-and-center, as with a blog). ... and also modify timeline
>> macro to reflect something like:
>>
>> *\define timeline(limit:"100",format:"DDth MMM
>> YYYY",subfilter:"!tag[keyword-alias]",dateField:"modified")*
>>
>> (2) In my case, an additional ViewTemplate footer template (a dynamic
>> table showing rows for each tag-child of the keyword specified in tiddler's
>> title, displaying exactly on tiddlers which serve as tags), and this also
>> needs to be added in to better mimic the original tiddler. So my content
>> for the keyword-alias tiddler empiricists is actually:
>>
>> {{empiricism}}
>> {{empricism||keyword}}
>>
>> As you can imagine, this is clunky, given that title-variants of X can't
>> be specified in the very process of creating tiddler X, and I need to clone
>> the above solution for each additional variant, such as empiricist
>> (singular) and so on. However the actual "weight" of each tiddler alias is
>> minimal, so effort is the main constraint.
>>
>> Still, it's finally possible to ensure that if a student posts about
>> *empiricists*, we'll all see a link that effectively invites us to visit
>> the keyword *empiricism*.
>>
>> Unless, of course, they misspell that keyword entirely. : |
>>
>> Note, of course, this solution is better for a use-case like mine where
>> those who follow these variant-links don't usually need to edit the
>> original. Since my students don't generally edit the keywords directly,
>> that's not yet a problem for me.
>>
>> Again, though: Any solution that requires a proliferation of tiddlers (as
>> well as messing with the timeline macro, etc.) feels less than
>> ideal. Freelinks will be better when a field directly in the "beacon"
>> tiddler lists all the title-variant strings that ought to point there.
>> Fingers crossed!
>>
>> Cheers, and wishing you all a season of resilience...
>>
>> -Springer
>>
>
--
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups
"TiddlyWiki" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email
to [email protected].
To view this discussion on the web visit
https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/tiddlywiki/24f0b986-11f0-4fef-a5c5-f517fda6f935n%40googlegroups.com.
