Personally, I agree with Justin and Costin that mod_jk should be able to use the uri field. Having said that, I'd like to point out that the mod_jk.c in j-t-c is flat-out broken. It doesn't handle the case where the '?' itself is encoded. Since this case is part of a currently popular attack on IIS, it will show up. ----- Original Message ----- From: "Justin Erenkrantz" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sent: Wednesday, August 15, 2001 8:27 AM Subject: Re: [TC3.2.3][PATCH] mod_jk / mod_rewrite bug fix > On Wed, Aug 15, 2001 at 08:56:45AM -0400, Keith Wannamaker wrote: > > I am concerned that the loss of original escaping > > will break somebody. For instance: > > As Costin pointed out, the escaping of a URI does not change its > semantics - they should be treated as identical by anyone who follows > the URI spec. Escaping where it wasn't escaped *shouldn't* break > anyone. > > And, the whole question is what does Tomcat see the request as? I > could make a case that it should never know about the unparsed_uri, > but only the uri that httpd finally resolved to and that mod_jk > picked up. -- justin > >
- RE: [TC3.2.3][PATCH] mod_jk / mod_rewrite bug fix Keith Wannamaker
- Re: [TC3.2.3][PATCH] mod_jk / mod_rewrite bug fix cmanolache
- Re: [TC3.2.3][PATCH] mod_jk / mod_rewrite bug fix Justin Erenkrantz
- Re: [TC3.2.3][PATCH] mod_jk / mod_rewrite bug fix David Rees
- RE: [TC3.2.3][PATCH] mod_jk / mod_rewrite bug fix Keith Wannamaker
- Re: [TC3.2.3][PATCH] mod_jk / mod_rewrite bug fix David Rees
- RE: [TC3.2.3][PATCH] mod_jk / mod_rewrite bug fix Keith Wannamaker
- Re: [TC3.2.3][PATCH] mod_jk / mod_rewrite bug fix Justin Erenkrantz
- Re: [TC3.2.3][PATCH] mod_jk / mod_rewrite bug fix cmanolache
- Re: [TC3.2.3][PATCH] mod_jk / mod_rewrite bug fix Bill Barker
- Re: [TC3.2.3][PATCH] mod_jk / mod_rewrite bug fix cmanolache
- Fw: [TC3.2.3][PATCH] mod_jk / mod_rewrite bug fix Bill Barker
- Re: [TC3.2.3][PATCH] mod_jk / mod_rewrite bug fix David Rees
- Re: [TC3.2.3][PATCH] mod_jk / mod_rewrite bug fix cmanolache
- Re: [TC3.2.3][PATCH] mod_jk / mod_rewrite bug fix cmanolache
- Re: [TC3.2.3][PATCH] mod_jk / mod_rewrite bug fix Bill Barker
- Re: [TC3.2.3][PATCH] mod_jk / mod_rewrite bug fix Bill Barker
- RE: [TC3.2.3][PATCH] mod_jk / mod_rewrite bug fix GOMEZ Henri