I really don't think "permissive" has either a positive or a negative connotation. It's a relinquishment of control, and that can be a good or bad thing depending on the circumstances. Regardless of copyleft licenses such as the GPL being a good thing, they don't relinquish control and are certainly not permissive; they give the right to use, modify, and redistribute under certain conditions. The copyright holder still has some control; that's how the code is prevented from becoming nonfree.

I really don't think we need to sugar-coat our language like that. Copyleft licenses are not all that permissive, but some of them are still free (I say "some of them" because a noncommercial license like CC BY-NC-SA is nonfree). Just point out that copyleft only prevents people from taking away your freedom; it makes the four freedoms inalienable rights. Someone in power has to enforce that, just like the government has to enforce your right to speak.

Reply via email to