"No true free software advocate" would *ever* use proprietary software, therefore, anyone who does *ever* use proprietary software is "no true free software advocate".

You really want free software advocates to pass a "purity test"! I only wrote that the free software movement considers that freedoms in our computing lives is more important than the technical quality of the software. The open source movement ranks those values in the opposite way.

The free software movement aims to have free software to do anything we want with computers. We are not there yet and sacrifices (such as using a technically worse program) are needed, otherwise the proprietary status quo will prevail. And, like I already wrote, a transition phase is needed as well: getting rid at once of all the proprietary software on all our machines is a recipe for failure. Like most users I started using more and more free software on a proprietary operating system (in my case, back in 2003 or so: Firefox, OpenOffice now LibreOffice, VLC, Gaim now Pidgin, Emacs, etc.), then switched to GNU/Linux but was still using proprietary software, then switched to Trisquel (but was still using one piece proprietary firmware), etc.

The "purity" you are obsessed with is the goal: today, a free software advocate rarely (never?) is "pure" but she aspires to this purity. Whenever she uses proprietary software, she is not happy with it. She seeks solutions. Hopefully, in the near future, it will be easier and easier to only use free software.

A free software advocate will use proprietary software when other values she ranks above software freedom requires her to use proprietary software. You gave several examples: not buying new hardware (be it for economical or ecological reasons), talking with beloved people who will not change their computing habits, etc.

It turns out I bought a free-software-friendly Wifi adapter (because my internal board requires proprietary firmware) and I do not use a phone nor a proprietary VOIP software (I use Firefox Hello). Anyway, I am not "pure": my BIOS is proprietary (importing one of the Libreboot laptops in Brazil would cost a fortune), I sometimes use proprietary JavaScript (for instance to access my bank account), etc. I am not happy with those compromises and seek solutions (anyone knows a Brazilian bank whose website works with LibreJS?). Who stands for "open source" would not care.

Reply via email to