Shaun McCance wrote:
>> Here's a list of the keybindings (and I refer to the Windows key the more
>> generic "Super" key)
>>
>> Super                to open up the main menu*, also
>> Ctrl+Esc
>> Super+E      to open the File Manager
>> Super+M      to Minimize All, Show Desktop
>> Super+M+Shift        to Maximize All
>> Super+F      Search/Find tool
>>
>> I think there may have been additional keybindings added in
>> since Windows XP.
>> Super+U      Utilities manager, a program to turn on accessibility
>> software like the
>> Mangifier, Narrator (text to speech) or on screen keyboard.
>>
>> Super+L      to Lock Workstation
>> (I'm finding it mildly annoying since I have hit this accidentally a
>> couple of times.  It is still nowhere near as annoying as the stupid
>> keybinding to switch keyboard layouts since it took me years to
>> discover what was causing that bit of evil.)
>>     
>
> That's eight keyboard shortcuts being taken away
> from applications.  One of those uses Ctrl, which
> we try very hard to let applications use.  You'll
> notice nearly all of our current global keyboard
> shortcuts use Alt.
>   
I think a lot of users would benefit from Alans proposal (and I guess 
Alt+F1 shoudl be added too for the main menu?). I wonder if it is very 
important that those keybindings are beeing taken away? Since I do not 
know Gnome yet I would like you to ask you a bit more in detail:

- With Super do you mean what I call "windows keys"?
- What kind of applications actually use Super?
- Are those applications perhaps mainly programming IDE/editors?
- Can an application override the global binding of super?

I can see the need for super in certain applications (like Emacs) but in 
the case of MS Windows I use the windows keys inside Emacs as 
Emacs-meta. Outside the windows keys have their normal bindings. That 
arrangement is quite good for me since inside Emacs I use meta very 
often (of course).

What I am trying to say is that for a user with special needs such 
arrangement might be good enough.


I got some more ideas about how to solve this, but I will wait until I 
have got some respons on this.
_______________________________________________
Usability mailing list
[email protected]
http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/usability

Reply via email to