Dear, When i am connecting through MSRD client to xrdp --
In idle mode Bandwidth utilization is low ,but when i move mouse pointer over windows and run my application bandwidth is utilized high. In reverse i am connect MSRD client to MSRD (windows) host in idle condition bandwidth is low , when i am move mouse pointer over windows or run application on windows host the utilization of bandwidth is very low. When connect to FreeRDP client-> xrdp ,bandwidth utilization is also High in idle condition. In running condition using freerdp client utilization is High. On Tue, 10 Mar 2020 at 13:15, ivanmarcus <[email protected]> wrote: > Manoj, > > I think the answer you're giving is 'yes' - ie. that the issue you're > experiencing is in fact between Guacamole and the Xrdp machine(?). > > In that case, for the next step, could you try connecting to your Xrdp > machine directly via: > > (1) MSRD client > > (2) FreeRDP client > And compare the experience/bandwidth utilisation of these two clients > (doing the same tasks, incl idle)? > > > > On 10/03/2020 5:48 p.m., Manoj Patil wrote: > > dear Mkie/ > ivanmarcus > > can i share a html code of MSRDC . through this html you can able to > connect windows machine. > share this html on that mailid or any personal maild ? > > see the snap shot . > > When i am check MSRDC at high network latency(600-700 ms) it run smoothly > . but in guacamole breaks the connection in time to time(connect-reconnect). > > Also we check at this latency typing is very fast there is no laggy in > keyboard typing. > > In guacamole to Xrdp at same latency there is keyboard laagy occur means > slow typing at client end. > > we also see when i am connect to MSRDC(windows) host through client its > take first time 8-10 kbps continilously transfer data in transection mode . > > in idle mode there is no any bandwidth utilization. > > > > On Tue, 10 Mar 2020 at 09:06, ivanmarcus <[email protected]> > <[email protected]> wrote: > >> Manoj, >> >> Perhaps I'm struggling to understand completely, but maybe we should just >> go through this one step at a time. >> >> (1) Is the bandwidth issue you're presenty raising between Guacamole and >> the local (Xrdp) client - NOT between Guacamole and the remote browser? >> >> On 10/03/2020 4:20 p.m., Manoj Patil wrote: >> >> Dear ivanmarcus, >> >> To be specific. You say MSRDWC uses a lot less bandwidth than Guacamole, >> however (if I understand correctly) from what you say you're using >> Guacamole with a Xrdp client machine, and MSRDWC with a MSRD client >> machine. I suggest you should first test with Guacamole to the MSRD client, >> and then MSRDWC to the *same* client with the *same* parameters and the >> *same* series of tests. IOW the *only* change in the lineup is MSRDWC vs >> Guacamole - NOT the client machine as >> >> I am done the setup of MSRDC at my place and measuring the sam scenario >> Guacamole to xrdp client ---- >> >> When connecting through browser to guacamole it's low bandwidth . when >> connect guacad to xrdp host its huge bandwidth. >> >> Guacamole to MSRDC client-- >> >> We test this setup with guacamole to MSRDC host through client there is >> also a bandwidth utilization . we measure theough wireshark >> >> MSRDC to same client -- >> >> When i am connected to MSRDC with same parameter of bpp, width , height >> etc and measure through wireshark there is tremendous different , its take >> very low bandwidth . >> >> When I am in idle mode in guacamole to xrdp its continuously check >> keepalive and bandwidth utilizated that time. >> >> When i am in idle in MSRDC there is no keepalive checking see in >> wireshark hence bandits is very low . >> >> >> On Tue, 10 Mar 2020, 02:00 ivanmarcus, <[email protected]> >> <[email protected]> wrote: >> >>> Manoj, >>> >>> We may have exhausted our ability to help. As Stefan has pointed out >>> there have been a number of suggestions and explanations around the issue >>> you raise; it could be useful if you were to pursue those in the first >>> instance. >>> >>> One thing that strikes me from your latest post is that you're >>> introducing too many variables when attempting to compare systems. If you >>> want to make comparisons then you should start with as identical a system >>> as possible and change just *one* parameter first. In this way you will >>> generally be a lot clearer around what changes have an affect on something. >>> >>> To be specific. You say MSRDWC uses a lot less bandwidth than Guacamole, >>> however (if I understand correctly) from what you say you're using >>> Guacamole with a Xrdp client machine, and MSRDWC with a MSRD client >>> machine. I suggest you should first test with Guacamole to the MSRD client, >>> and then MSRDWC to the *same* client with the *same* parameters and the >>> *same* series of tests. IOW the *only* change in the lineup is MSRDWC vs >>> Guacamole - NOT the client machine as well. >>> >>> Moving on from this, I don't have access to MSRDWC and have never used >>> it but if possible the next test might be to utilise it with an Xrdp client >>> machine and compare that with Guacamole to the *same* client. Such logical >>> steps would lend much more credence to your results, and may provide a >>> clearer pointer to you as to where the issue, if there is one, lays. >>> >>> >>> >>> On 9/03/2020 8:58 p.m., Manoj Patil wrote: >>> >>> Dear, >>> >>> Any Resolution on my Issues. >>> >>> Please suggest any changes at guacamole server and Xrdp host server. >>> >>> >>> On Tue, 3 Mar 2020 at 13:22, Manoj Patil <[email protected]> wrote: >>> >>>> Dear ivanmarcus/mike, >>>> >>>> The MSRDP setup is done at my end for testing purpose with same user >>>> ,same screen,same depth etc. we measure the bandith for singile session and >>>> it is too low. i am already sharing a snapshot in preious mail. >>>> >>>> *My point is if i used MSRDP web client to acees the server it take low >>>> bandwidth utilization . when i am using guacd with xrdp it uses high >>>> bandwidth.* >>>> >>>> >>>> >>>> >>> >> > > -- > Thanks & Regards, > > Manoj Patil.(Asst. Manager DBA) > Netwin Systems & Softwares(I) Pvt.Ltd > Nasik. > Mobile No -+91-9922507588 > Email- [email protected] > > > --------------------------------------------------------------------- > To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected] > For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected] > > > -- Thanks & Regards, Manoj Patil.(Asst. Manager DBA) Netwin Systems & Softwares(I) Pvt.Ltd Nasik. Mobile No -+91-9922507588 Email- [email protected]
