On Jan 16, 2013, at 3:38 PM, Michael Heydekamp <[email protected]> wrote:
> Am 16.01.2013 12:42, schrieb Cor Bosman: > >> Mail-Reply-To: michael >> Reply-To: michael, RCU >> >> The response will only go to michael, and not to the list unless you do >> reply-all. > > But then it still doesn't go "michael", THAT's the issue. Right next to the Reply-All button, there is a small carrot pointing down. If you select that, and then "Reply-All" you will reply to both. So this functionality does exist in roundcube. Not saying thats perfect, but it's there. > Or just one of the issues, as it will be expected by a) the sender and b) > the RC user that a reply will go to ALL addresses contained in the > "Reply-To:" header. > >> But i dont necessarily see that as a problem, because thats >> what he told roundcube to do in the roundcube settings. > > No, please see previous message. It IS a problem. You say, that when someone adds their own Reply-To in roundcube settings, somehow they intent to have replies go to both the list AND that address. Why? I would say they mean that all replies should go to just that reply-to address. Seeing as we already dont agree on what it's supposed to do, you can count on people wanting different things from it :) > If you still can't see it, please answer the following: Why should Mailman > add the list address to the "Reply-To:" header, if it wouldn't want to make > sure that any reply shall also go to the list? Mailman doesnt. This is a conscious decision by the list owner. Read this: http://www.gnu.org/software/mailman/mailman-admin/node11.html Especially read the second sentence. Trust me, this isnt the first time this discussion has been done. It is a constant and endless difference of opinion. And I also want to point you to this sentence: "When you set this variable to Poster, no additional Reply-To: header will be added by Mailman. This setting is strongly recommended." Here you see that Mailman ITSELF recommends not adding the list address to the reply-to. The reason for this is that people dont want to get 2 replies of the same message, something you seem to want. You're in a minority. Anyways, im not even sure the mailinglist software sets the Reply-To here, or if RC does on reply. Cor _______________________________________________ Roundcube Users mailing list [email protected] http://lists.roundcube.net/mailman/listinfo/users
