There is no profit in copying failure. I, for one, moved to OOo after
testing all the alternatives I could get hold of for spreadsheets and
word processors.  Even though I was used to MSO, it sucked donkey balls
so badly that a change was needed in order to stay productive with
reports and calculations.  I'm glad to have left.  I'm not glad for
idiotic yammering that there is recently some kind of obligation to
begin copying that crap.

If you want to make progress on the OOo UI, then find some specifics to
work on.

It has already been mentioned that full mouseless operation is needed
for the word processor and spreadsheet.  That's one of the reasons you
still find WordPerfect word processor floating around.  Professional
typists can use it quickly.

 + For the spreadsheet, that's a more mature tool and there are still
characteristics and conventions that are legacies from Visicalc.

 + For the presentation graphics, Keynote is very relevant.  I used the
presentation graphics extensively for 2.5 years.  It does what I needed,
but there are many things that can be fixed, especially in slide sorting
and managing templates.  None of that can be address by finding new
combinations of words to create the semantic equivalent of 'copying "the
ribbon"'

The survey really says almost nothing about what needs work.  You'll
notice that most of the questions were actually left unanswered.  That
goes especially for the

 - equation editor
 - draw
 - base
 - chart

For those, a negligible amount of answers were turned in.  Some aspects
of these may be under-marketed.  Or there may be showstoppers that turn
people off.

What will not work is the Microsoft-style solution -in -search -of -a
-problem approach, especially the deIcaza sub-style where the apparent
goal is copying crap with religious vigor.

Regards
-Lars

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [email protected]
For additional commands, e-mail: [email protected]

Reply via email to