On Fri, 14 Nov 2003 13:36:28 Pat Naughtin wrote: >... we should focus on the two most important ones: >> >> 1) Ease of use, and >> 2) Accuracy > >I agree, and I think that this is why millimetres are so successful when and >where they are used; millimetres are successful because they are easy to use >and they are accurate. > If for some industries that's what the use of mm would entail, fine. But careful though to extrapolate to ANY industry, that's all I'm saying, Pat. ... >I do not 'take sides' on this issue. My support for millimetres is not based >on intellectual arguments; nor are they based on the sorts of supposition we >often see from anti-metric groups. My support for millimetres is simply, and >I believe soundly, based on my observations of metrication in Australia >(with some observations from New Zealand and South Africa). I have been >fortunate in that I have worked in a wide variety of positions in education, >government and industry. > And as I said before, Pat, yes, your observations have validity, BUT they may not depict the WHOLE story, that's all. There is a lot more to deciding what prefix to use than just your observations of success.
Besides, I could also claim that the success of the cm in Brazil was due precisely to the arguments I presented. Therefore, again, let's be cautious NOT to *generalize*, please. It's also important for me to remark that I happen to have the same pool of experience as you, i.e. I also have already worked for all these 3 industries you mentioned! So, we have more in common than you may think... :-) >> This does not detract from my believing that Pat's arguments also have merits, >> mind you! > >Remember, I am not providing arguments - I am reporting observations - and >trying to give some analysis of them with the view of making practical >recommendations on how to conduct a change to metric. > Understood, and I'm for my turn saying that this may not necessarily be enough to pick a specific prefix. ... >My recommendation is that an individual must make their decision on what >works, as this is the ultimate guide to what is 'simple' and what is not. ? But what does that mean, Pat? Take the cm versus mm example. cm DOES work for construction, for instance, no doubt about that (it's what's used in Brazil and many other countries and I see no complaint, difficulty or any outcry for that to change!). By the same token you indicated that it ALSO works in Australia. So... Bottom line is, when faced with different alternatives, allow both, alas! >Suppose that 'an individual must make that choice' observes that the use of >millimetres leads to a smooth and rapid transition to metric measures and >that the choice of centimetres leads to a confused, bitterly fought, and >extremely slow metrication, then it would be a courageous person who would >then rely on the power of his conjecture and choose centimetres. > Perceptions, Pat. Please remember, what may have worked in one environment may not necessarily be true for another! When we went metric we decided to adopt the cm and there was no difficulty whatsoever for the transition, whereas I graciously accept that this did not happen in Australia, but, what can I say? Should I just point-blank conclude that cm is ALWAYS the answer? I honestly don't think so! So much so that the answer that worked for Australia was the mm! >> Having said that I cannot >> shake the conviction (or blame one) that would prefer to deal with only 2 >> digits as opposed to 3 most of the time, especially if accuracy allows him/her >> to. And I've cited one of my professions (pilot) as a strong argument in >> favor of that position. > >This is an example of the point that I just made. A particular habit has >developed in flying circles and a heap of jargon is developed and based on >this (as happens in many (most) trades and professions). Not exactly, Pat. It can be proven that the human brain when faced with circumstances that require quick reactions DO better the less information it has to process. A simple example to demonstrate that is to pose the following math quiz to anyone: Add: 53, 99 and 32 Now add: 534, 991 and 323 If pressed for time, which one would yield the quickest more reliable result if people would have to resort to manual calcs?! Again, please don't overlook specific requirements of specific professions, my friend. > It is drawing a >long bow to then use the evidence of the current practice to conjecture that >the original transition to metric was smooth and rapid and that the use of 2 >digits should (ipso facto) be transferred to all other areas of human >endeavour. > I guess there is a misunderstanding on your part, Pat, about my post. I did NOT suggest that dealing with 2 digits 'should be transferred to ALL other areas', I merely said that in some cases, circumstances may dictate that the wisest choice is to choose a prefix that would allow that to happen! >On another tack, Marcus may be relying on the mindset he developed during >flying training, and using this (his mindset) as the basis for his >conclusion that 2 digits are mostly better than 3 digits. No, not exactly. My point was that for some cases dealing with 2 digits helps a lot, and I cited my profession as an example to substantiate that. On the other hand, it's undeniable and a mathematic reality that speed, efficiency and all DO improve the less information one has to process. But, please, let's not forget that this is just ONE aspect of the story. Some professions NEED or require to have MORE accuracy, in which case the 2-digit option is moot and not applicable. > This issue of >mindset often bobs up during discussions of change; people argue from the >point of view of preserving their own mindset rather than being able to >observe the objective data. > Granted. This can indeed be the case, but I don't think I was saying that exactly, at least not universally, Pat. >By the way, I cannot see how, to an innumerate person, 2 digits are clearer >than 3 digits. > Not a matter of being clear but a matter of allowing those who have natural difficulties handling math use *less* information to help them overcome such limitations. Again, I go back to my simple example earlier. For Joe Six Pack, it can certainly NOT be denied that doing addition with less digits would be easier for them, then if he had to deal with 3 digits. Another example, why do you think people may show a tendency to prefer 12-hour clocks than 24-hour clocks??? Think about it! The other day when I was visiting Banff I encountered an individual on the street who asked me the time, to whom I answered 15:24. You should have heard or seen the look on his face! The same thing happened to another old lady I talked over the phone, same result. And, by golly, we're talking about a silly calc of getting the 15 and subtracting a 12 from it!!! :-( >> If it is absolutely critical for the well being and proper/effective/efficient >> functioning of a certain profession that digits be kept to a minimal, then why >> force unnecessary accurate numbers on this community??? > >This paragraph contains two unstable conjectures and uses them to support >each other - two drunks leaning against each other for support comes to >mind. Let me separate the two ideas: > >> If it is absolutely critical for the well being and proper/effective/efficient >> functioning of a certain profession that digits be kept to a minimal, > >This is simply not true. The evidence of the Australian building industries >over the last 30 years blows this conjecture out of the water; there has >never been any difficulty coping with 'big numbers' at any level of the >industry from architects and engineers to builders' laborers. ?? Dear Pat, you cannot possibly say that, my friend! Every industry is different. As I said before, professionals who deal with issues and demands for speed, reaction and similar things DO NEED an environment conducive to efficient, effective use of data information. If 3 digits is an impairment, my hypothesis, why enforce them? This doesn't make sense, Pat, I'm sorry. But here I feel we must part company. If as a pilot, or a physician, for instance, I were to be forced to process information containing 3 digits when I *could* do just as well with 2 I'd be the first one to vociferously complain and rebel against such policy, *period*! Especially if lives are at stake. I'm sorry, but there is *no chance in hell* that I would EVER agree to that! If I ever make a mistake because I couldn't handle so many numbers it would be MY BUTT at the line, not yours. *I* am the one who would be responsible for loss of lives or serious damage to property, etc. *I* am the one who would be sued and have my situation at stake, so... forget it! I must confess I'm quite surprised by your position, Pat. Oh, well... ... >> then why >> force unnecessary accurate numbers on this community??? > >And the extra digits did not 'force unnecessary accurate numbers on this >community'. In fact the additional numbers gave bricklayers, carpenters, >glaziers, and plumbers the opportunity - but not the necessity - to increase >the accuracy of all of their work. If a housing block of land was being >measured it was soon realised that figures such as 23 600 mm or even >45 350 mm were appropriate, and that 23 598 mm or 45 352 mm were too >precise. ? I'm afraid you're contradicting yourself now, Pat. What do you think the industry would do when it comes to developing *modules*? By your own admission they would *certainly* NOT develop "blocks" like 23 598! In other words, it's precisely part of my argument (in disguise)! If confronted with a choice, the industry would certainly choose to use **the least amount of digits** they possibly can! And you proved my point exactly! Now, why can't you adopt the same "leap of faith" and accept that if the mm itself is NOT required, and that cm would be just perfect or alright, that people use the cm instead? In other words, using your **exact same line of thought**, if 23 cm is appropriate, why make it 234 mm??? Or, to borrow *your own numbers*, if 23.6 m and 45.35 m is appropriate, why in the world go to 23 598 mm or 45 352 mm??? Just for the sake of making all mm? I'm sorry, but I can't possibly see your point. As another illustration I remember doing some renovations back in Brazil in the 80's. The bricklayer there was quite annoyed at some manufacturers publishing tiles data like 250 by 120 mm (these numbers are fake obviously as I do not recall what they were, but rather the *nature* of the talk I had with him). He commented with me something along the line of "oh, these dumb idiots, why can't they tell us that this is 25 by 12 cm? Nobody needs the mm for my job? We don't require to do things to that level of accuracy?" (he was reeeeally peeved!...) However for fitting a cupboard door, then 632 mm was quite >appropriate. Building workers had never had this level of accuracy and >precision before and they took to it quickly and easily when they realised >its simplicity and its value in producing a better job. > ? This is quite remarkable, Pat. Here you are making the same argument I am making but not realizing it!!! Perhaps you haven't noticed but each job requires different needs. The mm was a nuisance to my bricklayer, but the cupboard fitter required that. Again, why not give these two guys what they want? Let's stop pestering the bricklayer with 250 by 120's while providing the fitter with 632, or 63.2, whatever he's used to, this is all I'm saying! And if I'm a pilot who has to input data in my auto1 or the airport administrator, don't force me to enter 1125 mq therein or paint 1335/3335 on runways, instead of allowing me to input 110 or paint 13/33... ... >But 'for all people, for all times' is exactly what has been achieved by the >choice of millimetres as a small unit. But then it's the um for computer circuitry, or tenths of mm for dentists, etc, etc, etc... Prefixes are there for a reason, Pat. Please don't forget that. Engineering prefixes should NOT be imposed on EVERY industry, regardless. If this is your idea of metrication I'm afraid I'd have to be a formidable opponent of yours, what can I say?... But I'd certainly NOT support you if you wanted for instance to change our industry policies to force them to adopt the mm for construction in Brazil, for example. They're doing very well with the cm, thank you. If it's working do NOT rock the boat (please?...). As I illustrated in the Australian >building trades the use of millimetres was readily adopted 'for all people' >from architects and engineers to builders' laborers, and I have no doubt >that this will be 'for all time' as anyone who has shared the delightful >experience of working solely in millimetres will never return to other more >complicated measures, such as centimetres or inches. > You've got a good thing coming, my friend! You run the risk of irating millions of happy metric customers out there who see no reason to add another unnecessary dimension to their work. I can even foresee the reaction of my bricklayer (again...) to that... ;-) No, please, no! Please do NOT stir unnecessary controversy among metric users. Please accept our way of doing things, in the sense of respecting us. If you guys like the mm so much, fine, we'll give you mm, but be courteous in return and give us just to the cm, thank you! ;-) >... as extremely practical people they just use whatever levels of >accuracy and precision that suits the job in hand. ? Then why are we arguing, Pat??? Isn't that *precisely* what I'm advocating? Why pester my poor bricklayer with 250 mm if all he wants to see is 25 cm? > If their choices of >precision bear any relationship to metrological theories, this is purely >coincidental. > This one you lost me, sorry... I don't know what you meant. ... >Marcus has chosen an interesting example here; height (or more technically >stature) is famously difficult to measure. Our height varies from day to >day, and even during the course of a day. Perhaps Terry Simpson could help >us with some data on this. > ? My dear friend, Pat, why would one need Terry's help for? The matter is simple and you said it yourself. If our 'stature' (sorry...) 'varies' to nearly a cm, the case is simple, *scientifically* it's **wrong** to state it to that degree of accuracy, no discussion! ... >It is interesting to compare metric practices with pre-metric practices on >the issue of height. I can't say anything about the USA, but in Australia >heights were mostly estimated in 2 inch lots 5' 2" (eyes of blue), 5' 4", >5' 6". 5' 8", 5' 10", six footers, 6' 2" etc. The introduction of the metric >system has not yet replaced these convenient guesstimations with their >metric equivalents: 1.6 m, 1.65 m, 1.7 m, 1.75 m, 1.8 m, 1.85 m, 1.9 m, >1.95 m, 2.0 m etc. The attempt to introduce centimetre accuracy to people's >heights has largely been a failure here and you often hear people referring >to their own and other people's heights in feet and inches. I feel that one >problem here is that centimetres are too precise for people to guess other's >heights confidently. > I'm sorry for saying but this sounds like nonsense to me! Why? Alas, if you feel 5 cm increments is adequate, you would STILL have to write the numbers through this size interval, be it 1.6, 1.65, 1.7, etc, or 1.62, 1.67, 1.72, etc! Do you know what I mean? >From experience though people in my country have no problem trying to guesstimate (I >like that verb! :-) ) people's stature to the cm accuracy (I do it myself!). >Sure, we may err by a bunch, but this error usually does not exceed 1 to 3 cm. >For human height (stature), I use metres as the basic unit and guess heights >in decimal fractions to two places with the final figure as either a zero or >a five. > Good for you, but I use up to 1 cm and have been quite successful at that on average. Again, wonders of being fully educated in metric and using it my whole 45-year life span... :-) >> Therefore, as a matter of general policy we canNOT in sane conscience condemn >> those who would demonstrate a preference for the use of "non-engineering" >> prefixes when the SI system is built and designed with flexibility in mind >> (otherwise why would it have defined such prefixes to begin with if not to >> allow their use???). > >Of course we can condemn them and we should do so. Such people have >condemned their fellows to live through generations of bitter dispute over >what are, at their very essence, simple measuring systems. These people >should be further condemned because they are doing this from either >ignorance (they haven't bothered to collect any data) or from conservatism >of their own mindset (I was brought up using centimetres - they are good >enough for me so they're good enough for you). > Sigh... I honestly don't know what to make of the above statement... My first impression is to be startled, then disappointed then bordering the angry... Mixed emotions... But I need to be calm here and focus, so let me try doing just that, so... First of all, Pat, if you haven't noticed we should be on the same side, you know... Second of all, we are *NOT* what you called 'Such people' who 'have condemned their fellows to live through generations of bitter dispute over what are, at their very essence, simple measuring systems'. We did NOT *EVER* do such a thing! Quite the contrary, I see our mission as helping people use the SI system to the best of their abilities. But here is the interesting take and people can choose what approach seems more reasonable. The BIPM created all these prefixes, and I strongly believe they did so for a reason: **to be used**, and just not like just cosmetics. One side, mine, believes in giving flexibility to people, freedom of choice within the confines of a terrificly well-designed system. The other side, prefers to force individuals to look at ONLY engineering prefixes with no option whatsoever for freedom and/or choice. Now, honestly and quite frankly, which philosophy does one believe would stand a better chance of convincing the general population of accepting the SI system? I'll leave that up to all of you to find your own answers... ;-) You continued saying, Pat: 'These people should be further condemned because they are doing this from either ignorance' I'm quite sad by the level of your statement above, Pat, which I sense to be somewhat rude and even judgmental. Please remember that you're *condemning* your own brothers-in-arms for making choices that are *perfectly legitimate*. Secondly, you do not seem to be showing respect for those choices as you appear to suggest that they are out of 'ignorance' and not practical wisdom! Normally I'd be even angry about this, but I'll understand that you and your people are still neophites when it comes to using the metric system. So I'll give you a break, if only for the sake of peace and harmony. We have nearly 150 years of usage and advantage over newly-converted countries, so perhaps we should give you a chance to experience it a little further and see what happens, ok? But you continued, '(they haven't bothered to collect any data) or from conservatism of their own mindset (I was brought up using centimetres - they are goo enough for me so they're good enough for you).' Well, Pat, you cannot possibly overlook other people's experiences and behaviors. That's what makes this planet of ours interesting. If everyone ONLY loved the green what would be of the red, or blue, usually said my mother?!... :-) But for your info, yes and no. Yes, we did bother collecting info and no we do not use the cm out of 'conservatism', but out of preference and experience. I'm just surprised that you seem to not being able to respect that! I have no problem accepting your preference for the mm, but you do not seem willing to extend that same courtesy towards us who prefer to use the cm... Hmm... Again, the audience be the judge... >As to whether SI should include the prefixes centi, deci, deca, and hecto, >it is obvious that SI does include these and it has done so since the 1790s. >Whilst these prefixes are retained (for historical reasons?) they are >available for use. However, this is irrelevant to the thrust of my point of >view with respect to them, which, simply put, is that the use of these >prefixes will markedly slow down any planned metric transition. > And I can't share in your position. Perhaps it was so in YOUR country, but so far as I can tell you couldn't show ANY proof to substantiate the fact that it wouldn't for EVERY country. My country, France and Germany, just to name a few, are successful stories of the "kingdom of the cm", so to speak. Therefore, I have at least 3 examples that discredit your theory, my friend. I continue to strongly believe in the power of *proper education*! If we taught the SI system to people, the *whole maguila*, mind you, and not just biasedly favor engineering prefixes I can see no problem people using whatever prefix there is. We haven't, so why can't anybody else? But here is the difference, I emphasize *choice/freedom/flexibility*, while you seem to ONLY consider engineering prefixes. Again, people should judge for themselves what they'd rather do. >> So, let's please put this issue to rest for once and for all and allow >> professionals to handle how they should choose to operate. > >Sadly, 'professionals' have a long history of building ivory towers out of >conjecture and jargon, and walls made from conjecture and jargon can be >particularly impenetrable to the practical people who have work to do, such >as building from bricks, mortar, steel, and wood. > And yet you seem to not to want to listen to their very voices, Pat! (Remember my bricklayer, or that ma'am example of Chris Keenan?...). The thing is though, if you honestly think you can be successful at imposing certain views on people about this issue of prefixes I can only bid you the best of luck! As for me and millions of others I'm afraid to say that you will only run the risk of annoying us with such position. But that's fine because I know we'll continue to enjoy the *full* benefits of dealing with any and every prefix in the book and find more uses for even newer ones (like the typo). If that has a chance to make a significant contribution and help certain trades I'll consider my mission as more successful than bicker about mm, cm, or whatever. Don't take me wrong, Pat, but I find my time is better spent by listening to traders and professionals looking for advice on means to adopt the SI system to their advantage than to insist that the answer would ABSOLUTELY HAVE TO BE for the choice of specific prefixes. If there is one piece of wisdom I learned to appreciate and why one finds so many different sizes of units with the other decrepit system is *flexibility*, you see? I take the existence of trash like inches, feet, yards, miles, chains, rods, furlongs, etc, as an indication to me that applications appear to favor the choice of sizes that would suit them the best. The SI system allows that to happen with the prefixes we have, and even more so! Again, wisdom, my friend. Please notice that we do not need to leave the confines of the SI system to have such a diversity of choices that can suit so many in their own way! We can more effectively shut up complaints against the metric system by being flexible than by being intransigent/intolerant. But that's my humble view. ... >By the way, if we accept your point at its face value, then many, many >people in the UK and the USA would want to stay with feet and inches and >they could use your argument to support their . > Maybe... but maybe not! I'm merely suggesting another avenue. Perhaps we could stand a better chance of being successful if we sold the conveniences that the likes of in, ft, etc afford them as opposed to try to sell that the solution is ONLY the mm, you see! Besides, how successful have we been anyways in convincing them to join us? Couldn't it be that insisting on things like this may be the triggering factor, or one of them? I don't know, I'm just launching the question and not taking sides necessarily on this one. >> I don't honestly think metric users would be bothered >> much by being subject to things like 1.7 m or 170 cm or 1 700 mm. We can >> handle ANY of these with ease. > >But metric users should be bothered. He, he... But why in the world should we, Pat? The fact of the matter, Pat, is we AREN'T, period! You stand no chance of convincing us to start being bothered about the unbotherable, so to speak! If I like eating melons, oranges, apples and bananas, why should I all of a sudden HAVE to prefer to eat ONLY bananas??? That doesn't register here, Pat. If you get this decision wrong at the >start of you metrication program, you could be condemning your company, and >perhaps your industry, to a long slow death. Remember that if you choose >centimetres for your industry, the metric transition will be painful, the >metric debate will be hard fought on all sides, and the whole process will >be painfully slow (33 years so far and counting for the Australian textile >industry with many bankruptcies). But the fact of the matter, Pat, is that it WASN'T in Brazil, it wasn't so in France, nor Germany either! You are extrapolating your experience in Australia to *everyone* else! Why can't you accept that your assumption may be true only contingent upon certain parameters??? > All of this discussion and debate diverts >valuable energy from the fundamental goals of your company, or your industry >and it is all totally unnecessary. > But my approach is: look, Mr. A you have a choice of accuracy to deal with here, sir. Do you need things to be stated with mm accuracy? Then I'd recommend you use mm. Is the cm more than sufficient for your use though? Then I recommend the cm. Whatever choice you make though, do so based on YOUR needs and the needs of your customers, suppliers and stakeholders. Be assured though that whatever choice you make you are bound not to have difficulties with other stakeholders who may not share in your choice because the SI system is robust enough to accommodate diversity! There. What do you think Mr. A will do?... ;-) >> Anyways... my 2-cents worth... > >And for two cents many industries will futilely spend many millions of >dollars chasing the dream of an easy metric transition based on centimetres >without knowing that the centimetre dream is simply based on conjecture, >ignorance, and strongly held mindsets that some people developed as >students! > And I won't be fazed by your adjectives above (conjecture, ignorance, mindset...) to loose my cool, Pat. You continue to misinterpret my intentions or the nature of my position. You seem to be bogged down by my alleged fixation with the cm, when I only used the cm to drive a point home. My true and real message is that we should sell the SI system to industries and players with the complete power and force of what we have to offer! cm, mm, dm, hm, whatever, these are only TOOLS for a much more important issue, that of 'going metric'. And I can't *really* care less if they ultimately settle even for the mm, my friend. What I care though is that they come now and try to impose that specific choice on me, THEN you'll see me quite... disgruntled... ;-) > >No hard feelings, Marcus - I hope. > >We both know that robust discussion is really necessary for the metrication >process to eventually succeed, 'a touts les peuples a tout le temps'. > Well, Pat... For a moment I sensed you were somewhat... cruel there. But, I'll keep my cool as long as people can respect each other. The real problem may emerge though when my personal freedom be at jeopardy, then I may have to react to it. I guess I'll stop here otherwise this thing will be a monster. I may continue this elsewhere. Marcus ____________________________________________________________ Get 25MB of email storage with Lycos Mail Plus! Sign up today -- http://www.mail.lycos.com/brandPage.shtml?pageId=plus
