Daniel Rocha <[email protected]> wrote: So, you have seen a *sample*. Mats has data and he sees excess heat. >
My guess is that he has the same sample I have. Rossi says it shows excess heat, but I disagree. The people at I.H. also disagree with him. Anyone experienced making these measurements would disagree. I have made many mistakes doing calorimetry, such as the mistakes Mizuno and I reported. I always report my errors and correct them, whereas Rossi never corrects his, even when he almost kills people with a blocked hose. The errors Mizuno and I made were somewhat subtle, and they were not apparent until the reactor was recalibrated. Rossi's mistakes are blatantly obvious to me and to I.H. Perhaps Mats does not see them, but I sure do. The mistakes made by Defkalion were also blatantly obvious to Gamberale once he was allowed to do a normal verification test. Rossi's 1 MW reactor test is similar. I am not saying he made the same mistake. He made a whole bunch of mistakes! But they are equally easy to discover once you do it right. - Jed
