Ed,

Your are correct and I was too hasty in saying that LENR had been eliminated as a factor. I'm having a low batting average today it seems.

This test does not prove that LENR is not occurring. LENR does not produce detectable radiation outside of the cell. The only radiation of any significance has only been detected within the cell.

Yes. and BTW, what is the highest energy signal which you have detected within the cell? Are you finding soft x-rays in the cell?

Until the effect is tested with D2 enhanced H2, no demonstrated conclusion is possible about the source of extra energy. I'm surprised that so much energy is devoted to speculated when simple changes in experimental conditions would answer all the questions.

Yes, especially since Naudin has used D2 in other work. Maybe it is on his list (along with a few other details ;-)

One suspects that he is a very busy man with this and his other projects ...

...and IF he should have an adequate answer to the P-in power measurement question which George Holz has raised, and IF that rather amazing COP of 20 is accurate, then at some point, we may find that he will become less-keen to share his results than he has in the past.

Jones

Reply via email to