A paper by Widom, Srivastava and Larsen [1] explores an old experiment that
was reported in 1922 by Wendt and Irion, in which the two exploded tungsten
wires by discharging a capacitor through them and afterwards saw spectral
lines for helium show up.  In addition to helium, lines for mercury and
other unidentified elements were also seen.  Wendt and Irion thought that
the tungsten wires had completely disintegrated into helium.  According to
Widom et al., Rutherford did not think that the wires could carry enough
energy to result in nuclear reactions.  Rutherford also irradiated a
tungsten target with a dilute beam of 100 keV electrons and saw no evidence
for nuclear reactions.

A good description of the original experiment can be found here:

http://www.levity.com/alchemy/nelson2_4.html

I want to propose that what Wendt and Iron saw was the induced alpha decay
of the tungsten wires, rather than the complete disintegration to helium:

e- + 180W => e- + 4He + 176Hf + 2515 keV
e- + 182W => e- + 4He + 178Hf + 1765 keV
e- + 183W => e- + 4He + 179Hf + 1673 keV
e- + 184W => e- + 4He + 180Hf + 1649 keV
e- + 186W => e- + 4He + 182Hf + 1116 keV

The mercury might have built up through a series of reactions along the
following lines:

4He + 186W => 190Os - 1400 keV
4He + 190Os => 194Pt - 1500 keV
4He + 194Pt => 198Hg - 1400 keV

Since these are all endothermic reactions, the only way for this to have
happened would be if the alphas had sufficient energy, which they would
have, according to the first set of reactions.

Eric


[1] http://arxiv.org/pdf/0709.1222.pdf

Reply via email to