a.ashfield <a.ashfi...@verizon.net> wrote: Jed. "The Penon report is way more likely to be flawed. The guy is a > certified idiot." > > That sounds libelous to me. Penon apparently got his Laureate degree with > full marks. >
Don't be ridiculous. People accuse others of being idiots all the time, in both the real world and on the Internet. If that were libel, we would all be paupers. > You are sounding biased. I am biased because his report is damn nonsense! When people publish stupid reports I become biased against them. > I suspect one could trawl through your earlier comments and find where you > have made mistakes. > Not on that scale. Not published ones. And when I do publish mistakes, I retract them, as I did with my Mizuno report. > What exactly was this incredibly dumb thing Penon was supposed to have > written in the earlier report? > Read my previous remarks, or better yet, read the report and come to your own conclusions. Actually, there is a somewhat improved version of it: http://www.cobraf.com/forum/immagini/R_123487015_1.pdf Still a mess, on par with Lugano. > As I wrote before, if the report is so bad why hasn't IH published it? > Legal reasons I suppose, but I wouldn't know. When a lawsuit is filed, people tend to clam up. I wish they would publish it. It is irksome that they say they strongly disagree, but they have not revealed their reasons. As I said, rumor has it that Rossi is preventing them. I would not put it past him. But that is mere rumor and it could be wrong. The other things I have reported here are NOT rumors. People I trust tell me the Penon report has no merit. If that is wrong, they have deliberately misled me. I usually stay away from rumors. - Jed
