Peter Gluck <[email protected]> wrote: Dear Jed, > > nothing about the details- it is an essential question: > Is the excess heat different from zero Yes or No? >
Based on Rossi's instruments and data it is impossible to say for sure. They were intended to produce a meaningless answer. But most likely No. Anyway, you would be crazy to accept an answer from such a mess. Based on additional information that I.H. gathered, absolutely No. Not a chance. > Forget instruments, good or bad Forget the suicidal setup. > How can you evaluate calorimetry when you "forget" the instruments and setup?!? This is about measurements. Without the instruments and setup there can be no answer. There cannot even be a question. - Jed
