I wrote:

Common sense and the solid understanding of basic physics and chemistry is not sufficient for many papers.

Should be: IS SUFFICIENT. [EMAIL PROTECTED]&

Some papers, but not others. Not theory papers, for example. Not the papers about particle-beam loading or advanced electrochemistry. An amateur will probably not understand this paper, for example:

http://lenr-canr.org/acrobat/ZhangWSthemaximum.pdf

Abstract:

"Based on the Volmer-Heyrovsky-Tafel mechanism, Frumkin adsorption and thermodynamic data of hydrogen (deuterium) absorption in Pd, effects of surface parameters on the hydrogen (deuterium) loading ratio into Pd in the hydrogen (deuterium) evolution reaction are discussed. There is a change of mechanism from the Volmer-Tafel route to the Volmer-Heyrovsky route when the current density rises, and there exists the maximum loading ratio at a certain current density when the symmetry factor of the Heyrovsky step is less than that of the Volmer reaction. The theoretical results fit the experimental data presented before very well; other factors that affect the loading ratio are discussed as well."

I could probably translate that from Japanese, but I do not understand what it means in any detail.

- Jed


Reply via email to