Nick Palmer wrote:

Have you seen the Smart super microcar?

http://www.smartusa.com/

These cars are disappointing. They have lousy gas mileage. By the old EPA standard it was 40 mpg city, 45 mpg highway; by the 2008 standard it is 33 mpg/city, 41 mpg highway. My 1994 Geo Metro gets that kind of mileage and it is a lot more practical than a Smartcar. A Prius leaves both in the dust, and a plug-in Prius gets 100 mpg easily (plus some electricity).

I don't know why everyone is excited about this car. There is no point to driving such a small car except to save fuel. When I saw one I thought it might be getting ~50 to ~60 mpg. That would be worth the risk of driving one. I sure wouldn't drive a Smartcar one an Atlanta highway. (I hesitate to drive the Geo Metro on the highways here.)

The car is also overpriced, at $11,600 to $16,600. You can get a 2007 Yaris for $11,400, with four seats, 34 mpg city, 40 mpg highway (although the newer models seem to have lower mileage.)

- Jed

Reply via email to