Wesley Bruce wrote:
Jed, Another point you should consider including is that because America has failed to follow thorough on its own discovery and fund the research; other country's are also effected.
That is true, and important, but I think it is too much detail for this message. I want to keep it very short. If someone wants more info., they should read the papers and books on the web and in the bookstores. I don't want to cram the whole story into three paragraphs. If I were a busy science advisor type person, I would stop reading after two paragraphs if the letter did not get right to the point.
Some countries have been actively discouraged from working in the field by American government employees; Huizenga on his Australian tour in the 1990's.
That's terrible. Robin van Spaandonk wrote:
When you specify an amount, you run the risk of creating an artificial ceiling that you may come to regret. OTOH if you don't specify an amount you run the risk of getting too little.
I think the letter should state a specific amount of money. Especially a small amount such as $5 or $10 million, so that the person reading it knows we are not asking for the moon. Everyone knows that if the research begins to succeed actual commercialization will cost hundreds of millions or billions of dollars.
What I am reading a proposal of this nature, I get antsy when the author does not make specific, verifiable assertions and requests. We do not want to make vague assertions that some amount of money will be needed for some period of time for some complicated goal that ordinary people cannot understand.
- Jed

