Edmund Storms wrote:

Exactly how would you propose this money be spent and by whom? You can say, this is not your concern. However, somebody has to provide the answer. This is impossible unless the field can agree on what the consensus thinks is the best approach.

We do not need a consensus. Whoever answers the inquiry would provide the answer. If they return the call to me, I would direct them to Mike Melich, Pam Boss, Mike McKubre and the other prominent US researchers I listed previously (including Storms, of course). Even if other researchers do not agree with them and no larger consensus can be reached, I would recommend that the government along with whatever they recommend, because they have a track record of success.


Would you want the loudest or the most well connected to make this decision, which is what usually happens to government programs?

It is possible that the Obama administration will be different from others in this regard. The campaign has been completely different from any previous campaign in US history. Anyway, our people have the best results which gives them the loudest voice. And we are not talking about huge sums of money that researchers outside the field would immediately target for themselves.


While I agree letter writing can have an effect if it addresses an obvious solution on which many people agree. The CF field is not in this position.

I have never seen an interesting, developing field in science or technology in which "many people" agree. They always fight tooth and nail. In computers, for example, you have Mac versus PC. You only get general agreement in lifeless fields.


The information you propose to include in your letter is important but I suspect all aware people at the national level these days already know this.

"I suspect" is not good evidence. It is not what they call actionable intelligence. Anyway, you suspect, but I don't. I have talked to countless people about cold fusion -- including important people in leadership positions. Most of them are completely unaware that it exists. Many are well disposed toward it, and willing to look at more information. The first step has to be to bring it to their attention. You cannot expect Obama to do anything about cold fusion if he is completely unaware that it exists.

- Jed

Reply via email to