On Oct 27, 2008, at 7:40 PM, Mark Iverson wrote:
Edmund Storms wrote:
Exactly how would you propose this money be spent and by whom? You
can
say, this is not your concern. However, somebody has to provide the
answer.
This is impossible unless the field can agree on what the consensus
thinks is the best approach.
Ed, why do you think it has to be one particular way...
I don't think it has to be one particular way. However, only people in
the field who have been following what has been observed and debated
are qualified to make a rational decision. You don't invite your
plumber in to make suggestions to your doctor.
and I'm not comfortable with the 'in-crowd'
Only the in-crowd have the knowledge. I have discussed the field with
many would-be researchers. Many are sincere and interested in
contributing but have so little knowledge of what is known that their
approach would not only have to rediscover the wheel but would need
instruction about how it worked.
choosing which way is 'best'. Any rational person who has been
following LENR for just the last
year or two knows that this field is NOT sufficiently mature to say
that one way out of 10 is the
best to pursue, and putting all your govt eggs in one basket is just
plain foolish. If that one way
fails, you've pretty much screwed ALL further funding for ALL other
ways of doing LENR... kiss it
goodbye forever. Sorry to be so blunt, but bad idea.
I agree, all the eggs should not be put in one basket. We should
however be sure these are actually eggs we are using. I know of many
approaches that would have no chance of success. The field is no
longer completely ignorant of how the effect works.
If this were to be funded by the fed'l govt, then I think we can
assume $20M to $50M for the first
year, which is a piss in the proverbial ocean when it comes to govt
programs; i'd take it out of the
hot-fusion budget personally! :-) Sweet justice, eh Gene! ;-)
Then I'd fund 20 of the existing
research groups at a mil$ each. See what they come up with in a year.
Good idea, but there is no chance this will be accepted.
I think the goal for that first year would be that each research
group would work with academia or
govt labs to replicate each group's work. The first year is simply
an attempt to get some quality
replications done by 'outsiders' (competent scientists who have not
been working actively in LENR)
in order to give LENR more credibility by having repeatable tests
done by scientists who haven't
been emotionally tied up in the research for 20 years... Second year
would then focus on 6 to 10 of
the 20 approaches, and work on further replications and theoretical
models... no need to plan any
further out at this time.
The government funds programs using a well documented system. A
proposal is written, it is submitted to the appropriate agency on the
right forms, and the idea is evaluated by review based, in part, on
need, possible success, connection to other work the agency is funding
and opinions of the peer reviewers. Any proposal needs to take these
criteria into account. At this time, any money given to CF has to come
from another program, which will scream like Hell to prevent this
loss. As a result, the idea has to be VERY good. Consequently, I'm
suggesting the people who might have good ideas contribute to a
discussion about what such a proposal should be contain.
Ed
-Mark
-Mark
-----Original Message-----
From: Edmund Storms [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Sent: Monday, October 27, 2008 10:57 AM
To: [email protected]
Cc: Edmund Storms
Subject: Re: [Vo]:The new administration and cold fusion
OK Thomas, suppose your letter is believed and answered. Exactly how
would you propose this money be
spent and by whom? You can say, this is not your concern. However,
somebody has to provide the
answer.
This is impossible unless the field can agree on what the consensus
thinks is the best approach.
Would you want the loudest or the most well connected to make this
decision, which is what usually
happens to government programs? While I agree letter writing can
have an effect if it addresses an
obvious solution on which many people agree. The CF field is not in
this position. The information
you propose to include in your letter is important but I suspect all
aware people at the national
level these days already know this. The question is what do they do
about this knowledge? Without
this information, the letter will be wasted.
Ed
On Oct 27, 2008, at 11:35 AM, thomas malloy wrote:
Edmund Storms wrote:
As for a letter, someone will be asked to describe exactly how the
requested money will be spent, exactly who will do the work, and
when the promised results can be expected. Without a rational and
scientifically correct answer, all of the
I would suggest making the case that there are numerous experiments
showing surplus energy production, isotopes which are rare in nature
occurring in high quantities, and radioactive materials becoming
nonradioactive in weeks, not millennia. I would also mention BLP's
exotic material production. I would mention the LENR site, and the
documentation that it provides.
I would continue by saying that the mainstream scientists have fought
this technology by all means at their disposal. I would speculate
that
the results conflict with their preconceived notions.
However, I would hasten to mention that they have received over $150
billion in research grants, and that just covers hot fusion, not
radioactive element remediation. In spite of this resistance, the
research into LENR has continued funded in large by individuals.
I would conclude by suggesting that the government commit 1/10 as
much
to LENR as it has to hot fusion and Yucca Mountain.
--- Get FREE High Speed Internet from USFamily.Net! --
http://www.usfamily.net/mkt-freepromo.html
---
No virus found in this incoming message.
Checked by AVG.
Version: 7.5.549 / Virus Database: 270.8.3/1748 - Release Date:
10/26/2008 7:53 PM
No virus found in this outgoing message.
Checked by AVG.
Version: 7.5.549 / Virus Database: 270.8.3/1748 - Release Date:
10/26/2008 7:53 PM