From: Jed Rothwell Jones Beene wrote:
Their statement is either senile or idiotic, take your pick. Copper
migration is well known, and no lucid physicist misses this point. Kullander
misses it. Is he senile or stupid?
> JR: I do not think that this much copper can migrate through stainless
steel, so I doubt that can explain the presence of the copper.
You did read the patent application, no?
Direct quote from Publication number: US 2011/0005506 A1 Filing date: Aug 4,
2009 "An apparatus method according to claim 7, characterized in that said
nickel powder filled metal tube is a *copper tube, said copper tube further
including at least a heating electrical resistance,* said tube being
encompassed by a jacket (7) including either water ...."
* As far as I know, E&K are merely entertaining the hypothesis.
That is not what was said in the original public release. The two scarcely
qualified their enthusiasm in any way.
When you choose to put yourself in the public eye, as these men chose to do,
and you make silly errors - then you cannot complain if people comment about
your intellectual capability. That is what happens on News Groups - and it
is part of the process of separating the wheat from the chaff.
The message here is: If you can't stand the heat, get out of the kitchen...
And BTW - as I recall Rothwell has said many worse and more belittling
things about Joe Newman, Evan Soule and several other inventors here, and
they probably deserved it. We agreed with those because these men were
mistaken to the point of fraud. Fraud has not yet been ruled out with Rossi,
and it is completely appropriate to question the competency of anyone who
uses a University position to support what could possibly be a scam.
Let me make it clear - I do NOT suspect a scam but it is not ruled out.
Jones
<<attachment: winmail.dat>>
