On 11-10-17 03:50 PM, OrionWorks - Steven V Johnson wrote:
Robert,
You state:
You [Mr. Rothwell] may disagree, and now be 100% convinced, but it's your
personal attacks that are troubling.
Where has Mr. Rothwell attacked you personally?
Well, if Robert is claiming that there was no energy generated, then the
item from Jed which he quoted would apply to him, and that sure sounds
like an ad hominem to me:
"Skepics who claim that ... there was no energy generated ... are
ignorant. They lack 7th grade knowledge of physics."
That is not an attack on the arguments. That is an attack on the
skeptics, themselves. Jed has personally attacked /all/ "Rossi
skeptics", it would seem.
