Am 06.11.2011 14:25, schrieb Peter Gluck:
In such kind of friendly discussions, it is polite tio answer all questions, not only some selected ones. However perhaps it will be better to speak about usable truths, those that can be put to work to us.
I would like to do so, unfortunately I cannot answer all questions.
If it is about truth re Cold Fusion, I will ask you to take a look
to the 2005 Survey made by Steve Krivit and me. And to judge what's the situation today. great scarcity in matter of certainties.
For cold fusion, I cannot say anything conclusive.
I think it might be possible.
The number of Persons and groups that give positive reports is overwhelming but the evidence presented by the individuals is not so overwhelming and each group or person has different claims and theories.

For real discoveries it is just the other way. Only single persons or few groups give positive reports, but the evidence presented is overwhelming. Nevertheless all real new discoveries are doubted by most when they are still new.

Feynmans QED was laughed at when he presented it for the first time. It was defeated by all his high level scientist collegues.
It was finally proven by nature itself.

Lets take the alchemist phlogiston theory as an example: It had many supporters, but the evidence was low.
It is not the number of witnesses that counts.

What counts is only one witness: Nature itself. If this witness misses, then it is not absolutely proven.
Lavoisier had this witness on his side and won.


On Sun, Nov 6, 2011 at 2:31 PM, Peter Heckert <[email protected] <mailto:[email protected]>> wrote:

    Am 06.11.2011 13:19, schrieb Peter Gluck:
    OK, as far as you refer to science; can you tell a few absolute
    truths re Cold Fusion or LENR except they exist?
    If you have time please continue with lists of absolute truths
    from technology, management, religion (there are~ 11500 religions
    all claiming to be absolute truth), philosophy, ethics,
    sociology, politics, ecology? And etc.?

Absolute truth is only in nature, not in derived sciences.
Nothing made by man is absolutely true.
Absolutely true are the existence of x-rays, electricity all physical facts that we use every day. Absolutely true is that we can see stars that are so far away, that we couldnt see them if quantum physics where absolutely true. ;-)

    As regarding mathematics, I ask you to make a search for
     "mathematics was invented or discovered?" and if you arrive to a
    conclusion, please come back with a handful of absolute truths.
    Perhaps Kurt Godel can help you a bit. (he is dead but this is
    not a serious obstacle)- he says very interesting things,
    Absolute truth seems to be both an oxymoron and a paradox.

    It is  a common misunderstanding, that Godel and Alan Turing have
    shown no truth exists.
    The opposite is true. They have shown that not all mathemathical
    truths can be discovered and proven.
    They have proven, there is much more truth than we ever can capture.

    Example: Hilbert has shown that euclidian geometry is without
    inner contradictions and mathematically true.
    He tried to expand this onto the whole mathematics and this is not
    possible, according to Godel and Turing.
    But this does not mean, no truth exists. It means we cannot prove
    all truth that exists.

    About LENR:
    If we cannot prove it, we cannot use it and vice versa.

    Coomonly these parts of truth that are impossible to prove are not
    very important as long as we are physically alive, because we
    cannot make any real use of this hidden truth and reality that exists.

    Best,

    Peter


    a peterer, probably the peterest Peter on Vortex

    On Sun, Nov 6, 2011 at 1:41 PM, Peter Heckert
    <[email protected] <mailto:[email protected]>> wrote:

        Am 06.11.2011 09:43, schrieb Peter Gluck:

            My Dear Friends,

            Please read my regular issue of INFORMAVORE's SUNDAY:

            
http://egooutpeters.blogspot.com/2011/11/informavores-sunday-no-480.html

            It is a pleasure to discover, especially to discover new
            aspects,
            surprising features of old ideas and ancient concepts.
            Some 3 years
            ago I wrote an essay-editorial about lies: "Small Man,
            why are you
            lying all the time?"
            The main 'discovery' was that lies are relative, they do
            not exist if
            there is no truth. Each and every lie is the opposite of
            a truth.
            Now I had a slow revelation (it lasted some 10 months, I
            am not
            a fast thinker): there exists a special category of lies,
            Big Lies.
            Their opposite is not a truth but also a lie.
            Due to a memory glitch, I am not able to give you examples
            but I am convinced you will be able to find at least one.
            The things are more weird than we can imagine- as more very
            wise thinkers have stated.
            Peter


        In natural science and technology lies are not relative.
        Nature is always true and cannot be in error and never lies.
        Humans can be in error and can lie.
        But there is absolute truth.

        Lets think about the most true science that exists: Mathematics.
        Where does this absolute truth come from?
        Does it come out of human mind? No, it doesnt.
        If I write a letter then the existence of this letter is
        absolutely evident, testable and true.
        This is where absolute truth in mathematics comes from.
        Mathematics without the absolute true existence of written
        letters is impossible.

        Absolute truth exists, it is nature itself. Natural reality
        is truth, it is the same thing.
        Therefore lies about natural observable facts are not
        relative lies.

        kind regards,

        Peter




-- Dr. Peter Gluck
    Cluj, Romania
    http://egooutpeters.blogspot.com





--
Dr. Peter Gluck
Cluj, Romania
http://egooutpeters.blogspot.com


Reply via email to