Am 06.11.2011 21:07, schrieb Peter Heckert:
Am 06.11.2011 18:36, schrieb Peter Gluck:

What I wrote is connected to a subject more popular here these days. The future is unknown, but perhaps it could be useful to )re) read the play OXYGEN by Djerassi and Hoffman
http://www.djerassi.com/oxygen11/oxygen.htm
I have translated it in Romanian but the text was lost due to a hard-disk crash. It gives an answer to the question: who has discovered oxygen? Not an absolute answer.


There cannot be an absolute answer. There are many answers, some competing, some not. This is a little bit like the question "Were is the spring of the river Nil?". In reality rivers have many springs and one mouth end. (There are exceptions)

A big problem is, when you discover something new then it has no name. So, how talk about this? Many did research phlogiston at this time, this was the prevalent theorie and might have discovered oxygen and might have described its behaviour correctly, but the term "oxygen" did not exist and the physics and chemistry of gases was unknown. So there where no possibility to put this discovery into a wider context. The language needed for this did not exist. They would have used the name "phlogiston" or other names and so their description is not understandable nowadays.

So far I know, Lavoisier was the first who made documented quantitative measurements for oxidation and burning. He might not be this person that first discovered oxygen, but he developed these methods needed to prove and measure and predict its existence. Without this we would probably today still discuss about phlogiston theories and could doubt the existence of oxygene.


A little bit clearer is the question who discovered nuclear fission?

Otto Hahn made the experiments and Lise Meitner made the theory and discovered it is fission and there is a lot of energy produced. At this time this idea was not accepted and Otto Hahn was searching for transuran elements. He was not able to make the theory.
So Lise Meitner discovered fission? Yes and no.

Otto Hahn was nominated for the Nobel price two times before he got it. He did not work with Lise Meitner at this time. What he discovered is almost forgotten. He discoverd elements and it was believed this are new elements. They created names for these new elements. At this time the existence of isotopes was unknown, and the term "Isotop" did not exist. Later it was understood that Otto Hahn did not discover new elements, but isotopes and the substances he discovered where renamed.

Anyway without Hahns experimental research Lise Meitner would never have been able to make the theory. So ist is absolutely justified when Otto Hahn got the Nobel Price and is named as discoverer of Fission.
But they forgot Lise Meitner. She should have got a price too.

Best,

Peter


Reply via email to