I wrote:

> He aimed instead to wow the public by putting on displays of lights, that
> might actually have been in series, for all anyone could tell.
>

I believe one of the the first public demonstrations of incandescent lights
in series was made by Moses Farmer, in Boston, in 1858, 21 years before
Edison.

My impression is that the scientists attacking Edison were saying (in
effect), "There is nothing new here! You have not actually solved the
problem!" They were not saying "incandescent lights are impossible." The
public, on the other hand, did not know what was possible and what wasn't.
It was impressed by the bright lights.

The parallels to cold fusion are interesting. No scientist denies that
fusion is possible. They say metal lattice fusion without neutrons is
impossible. The public does not understand that distinction. Some members
of the public  have the impression that the scientific establishment thinks
fusion itself is impossible.

- Jed

Reply via email to