Every man has the right to choose what he does and how he does it .
I dont like to lie , but I dont tell the whole story everytime , and when I
feel someone wants to take something off me without paying for it , I dont mind
leading them down the garden path either .
Right or wrong if I had "The secret to the riddle " I dont think I would have
shared anything until I was able to control it and reap my rewards first .
Which would probably mean the technology would take twice as long to get out
there amongst the masses
Its the replicators of the world that really establish most new products
Maybe Rossi has done us all a favour , despite his personality or half truths
Pete
Date: Sat, 21 Jan 2012 22:46:04 -0500
Subject: Re: [Vo]:University testing of the E-cat question asked on Rossi blog
From: jedrothw...@gmail.com
To: vortex-l@eskimo.com
Shaun Taylor <shauntaylor...@gmail.com> wrote:
Rossi is a liar. Stop defending a liar saying he has the same rights to conduct
business as an honest man.
There is no law against dishonesty in business, as long as you do not cross
certain lines. Mostly arbitrary lines. If liars did not have the right to do
business, Wall Street would not exist.
Would you do business with a man that you knew to be a liar?
Not me, no. I have said that dozens of times.
Why trust anything he says, including his test data?
I do not trust his test data. I trust other people's test data taken from his
machines, and independent replications of them. Since these other people are
honest, that proves he is honest, too.
You have naive notions about life if you think liars are not allowed to do
business, and if you think that we have to judge experimental results based on
the personality or proclivities of researchers. Many researchers are
scoundrels. Many are liars, cheats or plagiarists. If we had to depend on their
honor, science would not work. That is one of the reasons replication is
essential.
If his Ecat works as claimed, Rossi would have no reason to lie.
I can think of many reasons why he should lie! He has no intellectual property.
He can't get any either, given the political opposition to this research at the
Patent Office, and Rossi's lack of knowledge about how the thing works.
He lies because the Ecat does not do what he claims it does.
You have that backward. He lies to make it look like it does not work.
Lewans now claims to have known the BBB never shipped and following that
knowledge knew Rossi was lying when he stated several time he was attending the
secret customer's US install site. . . .
For all anyone knows he has been to the secret site. Lewan and I do not follow
Rossi around.
- Jed
