Thanks, Eric,

Yes, that fits within my conceptual view of what is possible for hydrogen. I think Stewart has got things a bit muddled.

Andy.

On 28/11/12 08:29, Eric Walker wrote:
I wrote:

On Tue, Nov 27, 2012 at 4:18 PM, Andy Findlay <[email protected]> wrote:

I wasn't aware that hydrogen was capable of beta decay.
 
Beta minus decay is possible under extreme conditions.  But you would need to temporarily place the hydrogen you wanted to decay on a core-collapsing star.

On second thought, β- decay isn't correct.  I'm having a hard time saying for sure exactly what kind of beta decay it is.  I don't imagine it's the normal inverse beta decay (inner shell electron capture), since there are probably few inner shell electrons hanging around.  But β+ decay implies positron emission, and I don't see evidence of that.  Wikipedia refers to it as "reversed beta-decay" in one place.  The reaction seems to be:

  p + e- → N + v

Eric


Reply via email to