I did not see it, but from reaction One point that have been reported is that the put the blame of that scientific and human tragedy on F&P bad communication... not on anything about the community, paradigm change, conservatisme, hijack of brain by few extremists, billions hunting...
In a way, (assuming people did not misrepresent that film) it looks like the "history being writen by the losers" that I see : - about wright briothers being secretive (and sciam & journalist not being blind) - about semmelweis being too abrupt and doctors being too proud, not about his claims facing the current theory of spontaneous genesis, which get buried later by Pasteur who was a chemist and a carpet bagger competent enough to fight the consensus. - about germanium junction wjhose beginning and a discarded anomaly in the 1920s have been discarded from history when academic community fall in consensual delusion, manipulated by few extremists, they put the blame on the victim like any sociopath. 2013/10/16 Jed Rothwell <[email protected]> > I just saw this video for the first time: > > http://thebelieversmovie.com/ > > It was nice to see Martin, Ed, Mike and a few others talk. However, > overall I find this video is appalling. It is 87 minutes of "he-said, > she-said" fact-free blather. It does not present any salient scientific > fact about cold fusion. Not one graph. Not one falsifiable statement. It > features bits and pieces of interviews with a few people who know what they > are talking about interspersed with creepy music and idiotic voice over > comments. Mostly it is about some of the events in the first few months of > 1989, with no mention of the fact that by mid-1990, ~100 major labs > reported replications. > > - Jed > >
