On Tue, Sep 16, 2014 at 4:31 PM, Bob Cook <[email protected]> wrote:

>
> I remember that the SPAWAR experiments indicated He formed with the
> correct 24... Mev energy of a D-D fusion reaction.
>

In the SPAWAR experiments I recall ~ 10-15 MeV alphas -- I might have
missed a CR-39 paper that says the energy is more than this?  I suspect
that the 4He in the PdD experiments is perhaps not from d+d fusion.  I'm
very curious about a lithium-related reaction of some kind; e.g.,
7Li(p,α)α.  The Q value for this particular reaction is 16.84 MeV.

If I recall correctly, Ed would strongly disagree.  I believe Ed would say
that 4He is found in PdD experiments in which there is no lithium.  But I
think such a statement would need to be closely examined.  I vaguely recall
that the value of 24 MeV per 4He that was derived for the helium
experiments is subject to large error bars.

Eric

Reply via email to