From: Jed Rothwell
[Snip] evasive double talk
We should ask – why not – or why did Roulette/Pons – who had
access to MS not test at all?
* How do you know they did not test? I have no idea whether they did
or not.Then if you had the opportunity, and did not ask, then are you not extraordinarily gullible for not inquiring? We would not be having this discussion otherwise. * * In any case, their cells produced about a thousand times more power than Miles, and the cells were closed for 3 months, whereas Miles' was open and could only collect for an hour and 15 minutes. So if they collected and analyzed helium they would have found far more. They would not need parts per billion levels of precision. DOH! That is precisely why they should have tested - as they would not need ppb levels – which are in fact not obtainable, even today ! Geeze, are you so insulated from how the world works – that the implications of this lack of data from them are not obvious? The fact that they did not publish, but should have tested and had every opportunity to test - will lead even the mildest skeptic to the most likely conclusion – which is that they did test, they found the helium results unsatisfactory, and they declined to publish. QED
<<attachment: winmail.dat>>
