On Fri, Oct 10, 2014 at 12:06 PM, Brad Lowe <[email protected]> wrote:

If it were a clear COP of 3, it should be pretty easy to "heat a tub of
> water" or do some kind of obvious work.
>

This is the most frustrating part of following the E-Cat story.  In several
years of watching, I have yet to see unequivocal calorimetry, unmarred in
one aspect or another.  In a scientific context, there would be some
responsiveness to the embarrassment brought about by this situation, and
the calorimetry would gradually improve to the point of being easy for all
to accept.  It would seem that in the context of the E-Cat, such pressure
has not been as effective.

This is not to say that IH or Rossi owe us anything.  I just wistfully wish
for an E-Cat immersed in a tub of water and some simple mercury
thermometers to measure the delta T.

Eric

Reply via email to