On 31/07/2006, at 4:50 PM, Steven wrote:

Has anyone compared the quality of videocalling between Skype (including Mac Skype to Windows Skype), iChat to iChat, iChat to Windows AOL IM, Lightspeed to Lightspeed, and is there a general consensus as to which is the best
solution in terms of overall video and sound quality?

IF you have a good network setup, iChat to iChat on Tiger is by far the best quality. The H.264 codec gives excellent results. The problems is that Apple needs to work on it's network code. More often than not, the connection fails with some form of cryptic error. This usually happens on badly configured networks as I have yet to encounter the problem on a network that I have set up.

Skype to Skype (Mac or Windows) is on par with Pre-Tiger iChat. I be honest I haven't tried any other combinations.

- Matt