https://bugzilla.wikimedia.org/show_bug.cgi?id=60366

--- Comment #2 from Thomas Berger <[email protected]> ---
(Illustration to comment #1)

> [...] a
> BEACON file would list those P214-values pertaining to items which
> simultaneously carry P214 and P646.
> 
> Alas, the efficient way to code them would be by listing a concordance
> between
> P214 and P646 in the BEACON file (and formulate the #TARGET by means of the
> P646 number) but this is not specified yet. And of course this kind of BEACON
> file would be generated from Wikidata data but this origin wouldn't be at all
> visible in its applications thus implementation propably should be left to
> interested parties and not Wikidata itself.

http://beacon.findbuch.de/downloads/wikidata/ contains BEACON files basing on
"GND Identifier" (P227) for several Wikidata Properties routinely extracted
from the full dumps in two flavors: E.g.
http://beacon.findbuch.de/downloads/wikidata/wikidata_gnd-mgp-konkbeacon.txt
contains the concordance from P227 to P549 in an inofficial, convenience format
and http://beacon.findbuch.de/downloads/wikidata/mgp-gndbeacon.txt is the even
simpler official format - so simple that it cannot even show the P549
Identifiers or URLs and has to rely on an additional resolver
http://beacon.findbuch.de/gnd-resolver/wd_mgp I had to set up for the purpose.
A third form would be the following with complete URLs

 ...
 100055427|http://genealogy.math.uni-bielefeld.de
/genealogy/id.php?id=65162
 ...

or

 ...
 100055427|Heinrich Wilhelm Brandes|http://genealogy.math.uni-bielefeld.de
/genealogy/id.php?id=65162
 ...

This form *is* permitted by the spec, very verbose, whilst obfuscating the
identifiers used by the target application, and is still somehow more complex
than the one-column list form (and since this makes a difference for some
tools, especcially http://toolserver.org/~apper/pd/stat/beacon.php does only
support the simple form I usually don't publish this third variant)

-- 
You are receiving this mail because:
You are on the CC list for the bug.
_______________________________________________
Wikibugs-l mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikibugs-l

Reply via email to