Tim Starling wrote:
>Personally, I think the refresh is annoying, since it makes it much
>more difficult to correct typos in manually-typed URLs. If you
>actually meant to type some non-article URL like a CSS resource, and
>make a typo which causes it to hit the refresh, the URL you typed is
>erased from your browser's address bar and history, making correction
>of the typo much more difficult. Maybe we should just include a link
>to the search page, rather than redirect or refresh.

Mark Ryan redesigned the 404 page in 2009 and specifically removed the
meta refresh tag (cf. <https://bugs.wikimedia.org/17316#c0>).

The redesigned page eventually got deployed, but the client-side refresh
very sneakily moved from the HTML output to a Refresh header (cf.
<https://bugs.wikimedia.org/35052#c0>).

Neither bug is resolved, if anyone is interested in helping out. :-)

MZMcBride



_______________________________________________
Wikitech-l mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikitech-l

Reply via email to