Martin asked about OpenMAMA has a lot of reasons. At present we know very little about what will the future of this project. MAMA is very interesting but still worth to wait for more things will become more clear (docs, APIs etc.). Currently our discussion is heavily theoretical.
Daniel W dniu 4 listopada 2011 08:24 użytkownik Martin Sustrik <[email protected]> napisał: > Hi all, > > Let me ask an question: Would anybody directly benefit from 0MQ/OpenMAMA > integration? Does anybody have MAMA applications that he wants to migrate to > 0MQ? Or is this just a theoretical discussion? > > Martin > > On 11/03/2011 11:10 PM, Daniel Cegiełka wrote: >> >> I have mixed feelings about OpenMAMA. I expressed my opinion that the >> same functionality can be provided using ZeroMQ PUB/SUB +topic >> filtering. I really like a clean ZeroMQ API. OpenMAMA it seems that >> will have strong support, so the bridge for ZeroMQ is an opportunity, >> not threat. >> >> MAMA was a commercial product, which belonged to the NYSE. OpenMAMA >> now belongs to the Linux Foundation, so it will be developed as open >> source. Cooperation with TIBCO RV or 29West, is the search for >> solutions, how can you accept closed and open solutions. >> >> Daniel >> >> >> 2011/11/3 Ciprian Dorin Craciun<[email protected]>: >>> >>> Before reading my comments, please take into account that I'm not >>> against OpenMAMA (nor for it)... Both OpenMAMA and ZeroMQ are open >>> source projects, thus if someone has "an itch" to integrate them and >>> (either him or someone else) scratches it, the better for both >>> communities. (Also I'm not criticizing anyone, just presenting facts >>> from the available information.) >>> >>> But, after reading (and interpreting) the following comments, >>> >>> >>> 2011/11/3 Daniel Cegiełka<[email protected]>: >>>> >>>> In the near future will be published documentation for preparing >>>> bridges for MAMA. We just have to wait. [...] >>> >>> (i.e. we just have to wait (as in having zero intermediary >>> feedback) for a finished product (the documentation) from the >>> developers...) >>> >>> >>>> 2011/11/3 Jon Dyte<[email protected]>: >>>>> >>>>> [...] >>>>> though I suspect >>>>> many users would stick with the NYSE DataFabric , tibco rv and 29 West >>>>> bridges. >>>>> (Those bridges are not in the open source distro) >>> >>> (i.e. exactly the part of the whole thing which makes it worth is >>> "closed"... but even if they were I don't think running the backends >>> would be easy / cheap...) >>> >>> >>> Contrasts (and this is an understatement) with their >>> "Understanding the OpenMAMA Development Process" charta: >>> ~~~~ >>> OpenMAMA development is modeled extensively upon the proven Linux >>> kernel development process, where developers modify project code by >>> submitting patches as emails to a public mailing list. [...] >>> ~~~~ >>> >>> (BTW there is only one patch on the `-dev` mailing list in October.) >>> >>> >>> Also by looking at the current repository -- >>> http://git.openmama.org/OpenMAMA-1.1.git -- I'm just curious to see >>> how the next commit will look like... (The previous noteworthy one >>> `d0c45dd6d0e7c069cd9098f81f6775596efd5cc5` is about 3MiB in size.) >>> (Although this is excusable for the first code release.) >>> >>> >>> But then again it is a young project, and maybe things are >>> different than what I'm describing here. (See Jon's final remark.) >>> >>>>> However it does ship with a bridge to other open source middleware >>>>> called Avis. >>>>> http://avis.sourceforge.net/client_library.html >>>>> >>>>> If we could get the ZeroMQ bridge into the distribution , I don't think >>>>> it could do any harm. >>>>> >>>>> I havent looked in detail at what is required, but as Mike replied to >>>>> me, in the absence of any >>>>> documentation, studying the Avis bridge is going to be the best option. >>>>> >>>>> Jon >>> >>> _______________________________________________ >>> zeromq-dev mailing list >>> [email protected] >>> http://lists.zeromq.org/mailman/listinfo/zeromq-dev >>> >> _______________________________________________ >> zeromq-dev mailing list >> [email protected] >> http://lists.zeromq.org/mailman/listinfo/zeromq-dev > > _______________________________________________ zeromq-dev mailing list [email protected] http://lists.zeromq.org/mailman/listinfo/zeromq-dev
