Life gets even more complicated.
As Burke, Magliococca (the best source, a recent article in Pittsburg) and I
("Federalists or Friends of Adams") have pointed out, there was nothing to
enforce until the Georgia court deliberately refused to obey the order in
Worcester. What would happen then was an open legal question. best
guess. The Cherokee cases were a hot issue in 1832. if Whigs win the
election, they enforce the decree, if they do not Marshall winds up saying that
it is not judicially enforceable.
Mark A. Graber
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>>> [EMAIL PROTECTED] 10/31/03 11:22PM >>> The quotation is attributed Andrew Jackson in the wake of the decision in Worcester v. Georgia. It may be mythical. At 02:33 PM 10/1/2003 -0700, you wrote: >I seem to recall a colorful claim by some president or other, opposed to a >particular court ruling, along the lines of: "The Court has issued its >ruling, now let it enforce it." > >Can anyone point me to the specific President, case, and citation for >this? Perhaps Truman, in response to the Steel Seizure decision? > >Many thanks, >John Eastman |
- Re: Presidents and the Court Eastman, John
- Re: Presidents and the Court Ilya Somin
- Re: More on responses to the National Constitut... Sanford Levinson
- Re: Removal of judges; was Presidents and the Court Bill Funk
- Re: Presidents and the Court Conkle, Daniel O.
- Re: Presidents and the Court kewhitt
- Re: Presidents and the Court Paul Finkelman
- Re: Presidents and the Court kewhitt
- Re: Presidents and the Court Earl Maltz
- Re: Presidents and the Court Richard Dougherty
- Mark Graber