Hi
Some tunes are not in any specific key, but it seems abc doesn't have
any way to notate this. If I use K:C the song is shown correctly, but
this opviously is corrupted when transposing it.
Is there a solution withinn the current abc definition that I overlooked
or should we consider
consider extending the K: to allow K:none?
What tune has no key signature? I'm confused.
To subscribe/unsubscribe, point your browser to: http://www.tullochgorm.com/lists.html
On 18 Aug 2004, at 08:07, Atte André Jensen wrote:
Hi
Some tunes are not in any specific key, but it seems abc doesn't have
any way to notate this. If I use K:C the song is shown correctly, but
this opviously is corrupted when transposing it.
Is there a solution withinn the current abc
Phil Taylor wrote:
On 18 Aug 2004, at 08:07, Atte André Jensen wrote:
snip
should we consider extending the K: to allow K:none?
It has been suggested before, and seems not unreasonable.
Ok, so how to proceed?
Transposition routines would have to be re-written to deal with it though.
Currently
Atte asked:
| Some tunes are not in any specific key, but it seems abc doesn't have
| any way to notate this. If I use K:C the song is shown correctly, but
| this opviously is corrupted when transposing it.
|
| Is there a solution withinn the current abc definition that I overlooked
| or should we
Hi there! Thanks to the ones that answered my last question. In the end I
opted for re2c to create the scanner.
I've prepared a little bit more detailed description of my ideas for a
generic parser. Following Christian Cepel advice the thing has been named
ABCp.
Please head to
