[Elecraft] OT: question re: antenna/rig swtich

2009-03-05 Thread Greg Buhyoff
Group, This is off topic and I would deeply appreciate any responses to be sent to me off list. I am posting here because I respect the knowledge and experience of the people who are members of this reflector. This may sound stupid but I have not had experience with this before, so I ask before

Re: [Elecraft] OT: question re: antenna/rig swtich

2009-03-05 Thread Dale Putnam
Hi Greg, I have that arrangement here, with dual switching.. I don't run the amount of power you do, but have tested the isolation... of the switches, and am concerned about the amount of power that is allowed into the rx of the unused stations... I cured part of that with the grounded

Re: [Elecraft] OT: question re: antenna/rig swtich

2009-03-05 Thread Don Wilhelm
Greg, Theory says you should not have any problem. With 60 dB isolation and 1000 watts, there may be as much as 1 mW at the input of each receiver - that is 223.6 mV, which is a large signal, but still within the power handling capability of most receivers. In the practical world, if there

Re: [Elecraft] OT: question re: antenna/rig swtich

2009-03-05 Thread Julius Fazekas n2wn
Hi Greg, This might be a good question to post on the contest reflector. Stations like KC1XX, K1TTT, W3LPL, etc all deal with such issues with their Multi-Multi stations. I like Alpha Delta switches and don't think you'll have a problem with them. You could look for Bird switches with higher

Re: [Elecraft] OT: question re: antenna/rig swtich

2009-03-05 Thread Erwin Haynes
I had the very set-up you are considering building - also using the 4 position Alpha Delta switch. I am now converting back to a modified manual set-up. Why? the Alpha Delta switch developed a fault -- if you open it up you will find that the mechanism is a thin strip of metal which is pressed

[Elecraft] OT: question re: antenna/rig swtich -- THANKS!

2009-03-05 Thread Greg Buhyoff
To the many of you who took the time to give me excellent advice, confirmations of my ideas and things to consider and think about, thank you, thank you very much. I have sent emails to each of you who sent me private emails and would like to say thank you here as well to the folks who responded

Re: [Elecraft] OT: question re: antenna/rig swtich

2009-03-05 Thread Rick Dettinger
Don, Does it matter if the rigs not in use are turned off? I assumed that they would have more immunity to overload if the unused rig was not turned on. The Alpha Delta instructions says the switches are meant to be used for switching multi antennas and one rig or multi receivers. They

Re: [Elecraft] OT: question re: antenna/rig swtich

2009-03-05 Thread Don Wilhelm
Rick, I do not believe it makes much difference whether the rigs not in use are turned on or off. Any damage would occur in the preamp or mixer stages in most cases, and the devices are sitting there with their inputs connected whether power is on or off, but there also may be some T/R

Re: [Elecraft] OT: question re: antenna/rig swtich

2009-03-05 Thread KC9QQ
You may want to check out the products from TopTen. They are a little pricey, but they are what are used by many of the Multi-Multi contest stations to share six antennas with 6 high power operator stations. I just purchased one of their A/B switches to switch a single antenna between my K2 and