Re: Bls: [kisunda] Re: Kisah Imam Ali bin Abi Thalib as dan Raden Kian Santang

2010-08-30 Terurut Topik Aschev Schuraschev
Nya dina Nagara Kretagama ieu Prapanca nyerat cenah Sunda teh patalukan Singasari. Hal ieu kantos diributkeun ku kang Tirta di ieu milis sababaraha waktos kapengker dugi ka aya usulan sangkan ambu Richa nyerat buku peng-counter-nya. Tapi da sumber sajarahna teu primer bawiraos teu peryogi

Re: Bls: [kisunda] Re: Kisah Imam Ali bin Abi Thalib as dan Raden Kian Santang

2010-08-30 Terurut Topik oman abdurahman
* wrote: From: Aschev Schuraschev ascheve...@yahoo.com Subject: Re: Bls: [kisunda] Re: Kisah Imam Ali bin Abi Thalib as dan Raden Kian Santang To: kisunda@yahoogroups.com Date: Monday, August 30, 2010, 1:06 AM Tah upami Nagara Kretagama mah sanes sumber sajarah primer, kirang soheh. Benten

Bls: [kisunda] Re: Kisah Imam Ali bin Abi Thalib as dan Raden Kian Santang

2010-08-29 Terurut Topik Ahmad Sahidin
kekeke... mun teu lepat mah saur sejarawan Azyumardi Azra, naskah lokal teu kasebat sumber primer. Duka tah mun salira nyebat kitu mah. Da kanggo abdi mah, yen agama naon ge teu penting. Nu peunting mah naon nu geus dilakukeun Prabu Siliwangi keu tatar sunda. Punteh ah

Bls: [kisunda] Re: Kisah Imam Ali bin Abi Thalib as dan Raden Kian Santang

2010-08-29 Terurut Topik Waluya
Ahmad Sahidin ahmadsahi...@... wrote: kekeke... mun teu lepat mah saur sejarawan Azyumardi Azra, naskah lokal teu kasebat sumber primer. Duka tah mun salira nyebat kitu mah. Ih sanes kuring nu nyebutkeun naskah bujangga manik naskah primer, tapi wikipedia, mangga we baca didieu :

Bls: [kisunda] Re: Kisah Imam Ali bin Abi Thalib as dan Raden Kian Santang

2010-08-29 Terurut Topik Waluya
Nambihan sakedik. Memang leres lolobana naskah lokal tara dianggo jadi sumber primer, meureun kusabab eusina sakapeung sok teu logis. Tapi naskah Bujangga Manik mah beda, salian ti eusina oge kulantaran naskah ieu otentik kolotna, disimpen ti taun 1627 keneh di Musieum di Oxford Inggris. Mangga

Re: Bls: [kisunda] Re: Kisah Imam Ali bin Abi Thalib as dan Raden Kian Santang

2010-08-29 Terurut Topik Aschev Schuraschev
nyalira sareng ku seratan nyalira dina zaman anjeunna masih hirup. --- On Sun, 8/29/10, Waluya waluya2...@yahoo.co.id wrote: From: Waluya waluya2...@yahoo.co.id Subject: Bls: [kisunda] Re: Kisah Imam Ali bin Abi Thalib as dan Raden Kian Santang To: kisunda@yahoogroups.com Date: Sunday, August

Re: Bls: [kisunda] Re: Kisah Imam Ali bin Abi Thalib as dan Raden Kian Santang

2010-08-29 Terurut Topik Aschev Schuraschev
Tah upami Nagara Kretagama mah sanes sumber sajarah primer, kirang soheh. Benten sareng Naskah Bujangga Manik anu soheh. --- On Mon, 8/30/10, Waluya waluya2...@yahoo.co.id wrote: From: Waluya waluya2...@yahoo.co.id Subject: Bls: [kisunda] Re: Kisah Imam Ali bin Abi Thalib as dan Raden Kian

Re: Bls: [kisunda] Re: Kisah Imam Ali bin Abi Thalib as dan Raden Kian Santang

2010-08-29 Terurut Topik Aschev Schuraschev
waluya2...@yahoo.co.id wrote: From: Waluya waluya2...@yahoo.co.id Subject: Bls: [kisunda] Re: Kisah Imam Ali bin Abi Thalib as dan Raden Kian Santang To: kisunda@yahoogroups.com Date: Monday, August 30, 2010, 12:41 AM   Nambihan sakedik. Memang leres lolobana

Re: Bls: [kisunda] Re: Kisah Imam Ali bin Abi Thalib as dan Raden Kian Santang

2010-08-29 Terurut Topik oman abdurahman
hirup di jaman Singasari. --- On *Mon, 8/30/10, Aschev Schuraschev ascheve...@yahoo.com* wrote: From: Aschev Schuraschev ascheve...@yahoo.com Subject: Re: Bls: [kisunda] Re: Kisah Imam Ali bin Abi Thalib as dan Raden Kian Santang To: kisunda@yahoogroups.com Date: Monday, August 30, 2010, 1:06