Re: Feedback on cross stave slur

2017-04-25 Thread Michiel Sikma
Hi Andrew, Thanks on both counts, I didn't realize there wasn't supposed to be a slur there at all. If there isn't one in Beethoven's manuscript I won't add one either. My intention is to just engrave an urtext version. You are right that A4 is just too small. I'm still not sure what to do.

Re: Feedback on cross stave slur

2017-04-24 Thread Andrew Bernard
Hi Michiel, The Artaria engraving of about 1819 is freely available at IMSLP. This is very beautifully done, a model of excellence. Possibly better than finding the MS because I suspect it contains many corrections. http://imslp.org/wiki/Piano_Sonata_No.29,_Op.106_(Beethoven,_Ludwig_van) No

Re: Feedback on cross stave slur

2017-04-24 Thread Andrew Bernard
Hi Michael, The Henle Verlag edition has no slur over this section. What source are you engraving from? Aside from that if you need to shape slurs the best tool is the \shapeII function in the openlilylib library. If you need help setting it up, just mail me. Fingerings? Unless the composer