I agree with Daniel. Regards
Le Mardi 19 novembre 2013 7h57, Daniel F. Heiman
heiman.dan...@juno.com a ecrit :
Anthony:
Given the current state of the art, I would strongly encourage you to
use
Fronimo to set the tablature version of your edition. The cost of the
software
Hi Anthony,
I'm not sure there is any consensus at all regarding lute music in staff
notation. As for my personal feelings, if the original notation is mensural
staff notation, I would like a performing edition also in staff notation. For
practical reasons, it is nice to play from a clean
My personal preference is to see the edition in the same form as the
original manuscript, staff notation for staff notation, numerical tab
for numerical, 'upside up' for upside up, etc (with the understanding
that other than direction, I'm not inferring that numeric should or
must
(or
maximize them, if you want special effects).
Regards,
Daniel Heiman
-Original Message-
From: lute-...@cs.dartmouth.edu [mailto:lute-...@cs.dartmouth.edu] On Behalf
Of Daniel F. Heiman
Sent: 19 November, 2013 00:54
To: 'Anthony Hart'
Cc: lute@cs.dartmouth.edu
Subject: [LUTE] Re: Tablature
Could you not simply publish a facsimile edition of the original source
and so avoid subjective input and if anyone wishes they could then make
their own tablature transcription to suit personal preferences.
MH
On Tue, 11/19/13, Anthony Hart [1]anthony.hart1...@gmail.com wrote:
There are a lot of really nice things about Fronimo, but when you get to
baroque music there are some ornament signs and right hand symbols that
are not available. I have gotten around this by importing a pdf into
Photoshop and adding what I needed.
Has anyone tried Paul Beier's new tab
Dear all,
I understand wholeheartedly the need for a good tool for tabulature
publishing, but how beautiful are many of the original tabulatures! And
they all - also those that are not so beautiful - are very personal! So
why not write also nowadays by your own hand? No limitations in the
On 11/19/2013 11:44 AM, Arto Wikla wrote:
Dear all,
I understand wholeheartedly the need for a good tool for tabulature publishing,
but how beautiful are many of the original
tabulatures! And they all - also those that are not so beautiful - are very
personal! So why not write also nowadays
Regarding hand written music---
If given a choice, I would always prefer hand written tab to computer
tab, especially with baroque music. I am baffled why anyone would
choose computer over original, when the original is so clear and
beautiful. When the original is not legible that
Anthony:
Given the current state of the art, I would strongly encourage you to use
Fronimo to set the tablature version of your edition. The cost of the
software is moderate given the amount of time and effort that has been put
into creating it. Input of tablature is very easy and very quick.
10 matches
Mail list logo
